Your 401(k), 403(b) and IRA: Tax Shelter or Tax Nightmare?

When it comes to taxes, our goal is to keep it in the family. And I know that Uncle Sam looks like a nice guy, but he just isn’t part of your family.

You don’t have to go very far back into the history of our country to find tax rates that were easily double what they are today.

For example, during the last two years of World War II, the highest marginal tax bracket was 94%. Throughout much of the 1960s, it was between 70% and 90%.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

Pressure Mounts to Raise Taxes in Future

What was true of the past might be true for the future. Today, the top marginal rate is 39.6%, and if you add the 3.8% percent surtax on investment income, you are at 43.4%.

Let’s look at the fiscal challenges facing our country.

As of 2016, the majority of every tax dollar that comes into the U.S. Treasury goes to pay for only four things: Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and interest on the national debt.

As Baby Boomers march into retirement and onto the rolls of the entitlement programs over the course of the next 10 years, they are going to stop putting money into Social Security and Medicare; they are going to want to start taking money out. As they do, the costs for these four big ticket items will balloon.

By looking back at the last several years, we can already see the percentage of tax dollars going to Medicare and Medicaid rise. In 2016, 29.1% of every tax dollar went to cover health programs (including both Medicare and Medicaid) compared with only 20% of every tax dollar in 2012. This is the only category that has seen a significant increase every year for the last five years. This means there are fewer of our tax dollars to pay for everything else, including disaster relief, the IRS, the armed services, basic welfare programs like food stamps, the EPA, Centers for Disease Control, the cost of running Congress, the FBI, the CIA and dozens of other programs.

When 2020 rolls around, where will the government go to find the money to pay all its bills? I don’t have a crystal ball, but you can guess where the tax rates are likely to go from here.

How Tax-Deferred Savings Can Catch Up with You

In my experience, most retirees and pre-retirees have the majority of their savings in 401(k) and individual retirement accounts, or IRAs. Traditional versions of these accounts may have never paid taxes. If you’re one of those people with the majority of your savings in one of those retirement accounts, you need to realize not all that money is yours. You have a partner in your accounts, Uncle Sam, who with a stroke of a pen can increase his share and reduce yours.

On top of it, there are a few other things that the withdrawals from your 401(k), 403(b) and IRA accounts can impact:

• Uncle Sam is going to tax every dollar that comes out at whatever your highest tax bracket is.
• Each distribution can potentially push you into the higher tax bracket.
• Every dollar you withdraw has the potential to increase a tax you pay on your Social Security.
• Each distribution can increase your exposure to the 3.8% surtax on investment income.
• You might have to include more of your Social Security benefits as taxable income, and your Medicare Part B premiums can increase.
• These tax-deferred accounts are the only assets that force you to withdraw money, even if you don’t want to: Required minimum distributions, or RMDs, start at age 70½. Failing to take your RMD can trigger a 50% tax on those funds.

One Tax-Reduction Strategy: Roth IRA Conversion

One of the strategies to potentially reduce the impact of taxes is a Roth IRA conversion. By converting to a Roth IRA, you may help protect your savings from a potential tax increase in the future, by paying tax at today’s known rates.

Also, since Roth IRA distributions in retirement are tax-free (as long as you’re at least 59½ and have held your Roth account for at least five years) they typically don’t impact other things tied to your income. For instance, tax-free Roth IRA distributions are not part of the calculation that determines how much of your Social Security income is taxable, so they can help to reduce that expense. They can also help you keep other costs tied to your income lower, such as your Medicare Part B premiums or health insurance subsidies.

Another big benefit is that Roth IRAs have no required minimum distributions during your lifetime.

So, during your retirement, you can take as much, or as little, as you want. You’re not forced to take anything at 70½ if you don’t want to, like you are with your traditional IRAs or 401(k) plans.

That means your Roth IRA can continue to grow, tax-free, for your heirs. That makes the Roth IRA a very good vehicle from an estate-planning perspective.

And, speaking of your beneficiaries, non-spouse beneficiaries, like children, do have RMDs from inherited Roth IRA accounts after the owner dies, but those distributions will generally be tax-free as well.

Another Strategy: Filling Up the Bracket

One of the strategies that some might consider as they ease into retirement is a Roth IRA strategy called “filling up the bracket,” where you focus on timing your Roth conversions with your tax bracket in mind.

Here is an example. Let’s assume we have a couple, still working, and planning to retire in two years. While they are working, the combined household income is $120,000 annually. Their effective tax rate is 14%. In two years, they will reach age 66 and retire.

Since they have no debt, they have calculated that, in retirement, they will need $55,000 per year on which to live. They are expecting $30,000 from Social Security and about $25,000 from IRA accounts for a total $55,000. From the time they retire at age 66 and until they reach age 70½, (when they have to begin taking their RMDs), our hypothetical couple will find themselves in a much lower tax bracket.

At this point, it makes sense for them to sit down with the qualified tax professional and review a few options for converting portions of their IRA and 401(k) accounts into a Roth IRA while in the lower tax bracket.

These kinds of tax-reduction techniques should be and are a very important part of your overall retirement plan. Your financial professional should be discussing this with you. This is your financial professional’s job, to create a written plan for you and to help guide you on the path toward your retirement.

Before considering a Roth IRA conversion, please consult with a qualified tax professional.