When it comes to investing, there are two main types of people: those who pick stocks and those who gravitate to funds. The stock pickers, rightly or wrongly, tend to have a pretty high opinion of their investing abilities. Fund investors are willing to let the pros make the decisions.
But fund investors aren't off the hook altogether. Funds have their own vernacular -- total return, style, decile rank and so on. Knowing what they mean, what's good and what's bad can help you compare funds and pick the best one.
Performance counts
Beginning investors tend to zero in on a fund's return, and although it's not the only thing to check out, it's a good place to start.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
If you're sorting funds using Kiplinger's Fund Finder, the one-year return you see listed is the fund's total return for a 12-month period. The three- and five-year returns are annualized returns. In other words, they are the total returns averaged over three and five years.
Total return is the change in the value of the investment, assuming dividends and capital gains were put back into the fund rather than paid out to shareholders. Total returns also factor in a fund's expenses (but don't account for any sales or redemption fees). They are, in short, a fund's bottom line.
Returns alone don't give you the whole picture. One key thing to consider when looking at returns is to make sure that the fund is at least a year old, says Morningstar fund analyst Peter Di Teresa. "The longer the record the better, but even that has a caveat," he says. If you spot a fund with an impressive record, you need to find out whether the manager who earned it is still in charge.
Fund Finder includes a column that tells you how long a fund's manager has held the reigns. You can also get that information by ordering a prospectus or visiting a fund company's Web site.
Be aware, however, that annualized returns, because they're averaged, can mask a horrendous year (for more on that, see decile rank, below). And if you have a truly diversified portfolio, you're going to own funds whose style of investing may have temporarily gone out of favor -- and they may not show up at the top of the total return heap.
Bottom line: Finding a fund that had a great run in the past is a good starting point. But there's no guarantee that it will continue to serve up plum returns in the future. A better way to gauge a fund's performance is to see how it measures up against its peers.
Peer review
When weighing your fund options, "you have to make an apples-to-apples comparison," says Di Teresa. The way to do that is to compare funds only if they are in the same category and have the same investment style.
What's the difference? Category tells you how completely a fund invests its assets and how much risk it assumes. Categories are subsections of the various fund universes -- U.S. stock funds, foreign stock funds, bond funds.
Style gets more specific. Think of style as a loose description of what the fund looks for in a particular stock, whether it's value, growth, big or small companies or some combination thereof.
The best way to see how a fund measures up against its peers, year after year, is to look at its decile rank. Fund Finder shows a fund's decile rank among other funds with that style over a five-year period. A fund that ranks number one posted performance that puts it among the top 10% of its peers.
Bottom line: Before you bite, check to see how consistent the fund is over time. Unlike annualized returns, bummer years have no place to hide in decile rankings.
Benchmark basics
Turn on CNBC or flip through the ads in personal finance magazines and you're bound to see a manager bragging that his or her fund beat the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index for so many years in a row.
The SP 500 is an index that measures the performance of the largest 500 companies in the U.S. stock market (there are also funds that mimic the performance of the SP index). Funds that invest in large-company stocks use the SP as a benchmark, and it's useful because it sets up a standard for comparing mutual funds that invest in large-company stocks.
Small-company funds tend to use the Russell 2000 as a benchmark, and mid-size funds tend to use the Russell Midcap index. Russell has 21 different indexes, and SP has at least seven for U.S. stocks alone, so fund managers can easily find a benchmark that matches their stock-picking style. (For more on the bellwethers and the types of stocks they measure, see Russell.com and Standardandpoors.com).
Bottom line: If a fund says it beat an index, make sure it's an appropriate benchmark. Otherwise the manager isn't making a fair comparison.
For more help on getting a handle on mutual funds, see "Demystifying the Mutual Fund, Part 2."
-
Start-ups Trying to (Profitably) Solve the World’s Hardest ProblemsThe Letter More investors are interested in companies working on breakthrough science to tackle huge societal challenges. The field of deep tech has major tailwinds, too.
-
The Big Questions for AR’s FutureThe Letter As Meta shows off a flashy AR prototype, Microsoft quietly stops supporting its own AR headset. The two companies highlight the promise and peril of AR.
-
China's Economy Faces Darkening OutlookThe Letter What the slowdown in China means for U.S. businesses.
-
Should We Worry About the Slowing U.S. EconomyThe Letter With the labor market cooling off and financial markets turning jittery, just how healthy is the economy right now?
-
Kiplinger Special: How Businesses Should Budget for 2025Kiplinger Forecasts From fuel to AI software subscriptions, here's what you can expect to pay next year.
-
Intel Braces for an Even Tougher Road AheadThe Kiplinger Letter Amid a long, costly turnaround, Intel resets expectations again. Its new woes raise questions about U.S. industrial policy and global chip competition.
-
Kiplinger Special: The Long-Term Future of the U.S. Economy
The Kiplinger Letter Kiplinger's report into what it will take the U.S. to maintain a healthy economic growth rate.
-
Fed Rate Cuts Still on HoldThe Kiplinger Letter With inflation stubbornly elevated, the Federal Reserve will keep interest rates high for now.
