Q. My friend and I disagree about the proposal for universal free tuition for two years of community college—the ethics, cost and benefit to society. How do you view it?
See Also -- TOOL: Find the Best College for You
A. First of all, let’s not call this proposed program “free.” It might not cost the students anything, but it wouldn’t be free to the taxpayers who would fund it.
As for the ethics of it: Remember that every new governmental entitlement ever proposed—whether it was universal public elementary and secondary schooling in the 19th century, Social Security (funded by a tax on employers and workers), or "free" health care for the poor (Medicaid)—was promoted as an ethical imperative for a compassionate society. An ethical case, however valid or lame, can be made for virtually every governmental expenditure.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Let's focus instead on whether this would be a cost-effective way to improve the capability of the American workforce, which is an important goal in a competitive global economy. Well, at an estimated cost of $60 billion over 10 years, maybe it would be—but maybe not.
First, it needn’t be a new federal entitlement. The states—which, sadly, have been cutting their commitment to their public colleges—could do this their own way, as Tennessee and Oregon already have and more states are contemplating. So could counties and cities, which operate most community colleges. (Chicago started its two-years-free program last year.)
Perhaps community colleges should focus on reducing their very high dropout rates rather than filling their classrooms with even more high school graduates. And a smoother transfer path to public four-year colleges is needed, too.
The federal government's Pell Grant program already makes two years of community college virtually free to poor students, and it could be enlarged to benefit middle-class students as well.
See Also -- Knight Kiplinger's Money & Ethics Quiz
Young Americans definitely need post-secondary training of some sort—if not at a four-year college, then at a vocational/technical school, community college or apprenticeship—to earn a decent living. Using taxpayer funds to help them do so would be money well spent. The challenge is figuring out how to do it most sensibly.
-
You Don’t Want to Retire in Portugal: Here Are Three Tax Reasons WhyRetirement Taxes With the NHR benefit retiring and pension taxes increasing, you might rethink your retirement plans in Portugal.
-
Home Depot's Winning Ways Fueled Its 100,000% ReturnHome Depot's wide moat leaves little room for competition – and shareholders have profited as a result.
-
How Intrafamily Loans Can Bridge the Education Funding GapTo avoid triggering federal gift taxes, a family member can lend a student money for education at IRS-set interest rates. Here's what to keep in mind.
-
How an Irrevocable Trust Could Pay for EducationAn education trust can be set up for one person or multiple people, and the trust maker decides how the money should be used and at what age.
-
UTMA: A Flexible Alternative for Education Expenses and MoreThis custodial account can be used to pay for anything once the beneficiary is considered an adult in their state. There are some considerations, though.
-
Coverdell Education Savings Accounts: A Deep DiveWhile there are some limitations on income and contributions, as well as other restrictions, a Coverdell can be a bit more flexible than a 529 plan.
-
529 Plans: A Powerful Way to Tackle Rising Education CostsContributions to 529 plans grow tax-free and are not taxed when they are used to pay for qualified educational expenses for the beneficiary.
-
Are Student Loans Being Forgiven or Not?Student Loans The House and Senate voted to repeal President Biden’s student loan forgiveness plan, but does it even matter?
-
Are Scholarships Always Tax-Free? What You Need to KnowEducation Scholarships are generally tax-free if certain IRS and other requirements are met.
-
Student Loan Forgiveness Blocked For Now Due to Court RulingsBiden's student loan debt forgiveness program is on hold until the U.S. Supreme Court weighs in.
