I’ve spent over 25 years in the financial advisory profession but recently had a startling realization about investment performance. During a friendly debate with a friend who manages a small-cap mutual fund, I realized even seasoned investment professionals can have misperceptions about investment performance. My friend had a fixation on top quartile performance, a key measure of his professional ranking, but one with little application in the real world — where clients typically own mutual funds representing various asset classes.
Our debate got me to thinking: How should the average investor measure investment performance? I recommend investors focus on two components of performance:
How is my performance number calculated?
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
How is my account doing relative to a fair benchmark?
Your Performance Calculation
The performance calculation methodology involves two key variables: 1) the mathematical formula used to produce a return figure and 2) the portfolio(s) that are being measured. Most professional money managers use a Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) compliant methodology to calculate investment performance. Brokers, Registered Investment Advisers and custodians often provide performance information to clients in their account statements. It is important to ask your provider if their performance report uses an approved GIPS methodology. Time-weighted returns are the most commonly used measure.
Interestingly, GIPS does not require investment performance to be reported net of fees. Consumers would be wise to ask their adviser for performance reports net of fees. After all, it’s not what you earn, it’s what you keep that is important.
Equally important is understanding whether the performance number is specific to your account, or merely a listing of the performance of each mutual fund. According to the GIPS guidance statement on fees, “The GIPS standards are based on the concept of presenting composite performance to prospective clients rather than presenting individual portfolio returns to existing clients (emphasis added).” Very simply, it is permissible for a broker or custodian to show a performance number on your statement for XYZ mutual fund that may or may not be your actual investment performance.
I’ve seen brokerage statements list a client’s various mutual fund’s performance, but not include the client’s overall account performance. Investors should ask their adviser for their specific account’s performance net of all fees. Most advisers have software that can calculate this.
Which Benchmark to Use
What about benchmarks? How can investors gauge their performance relative to other alternatives? This simple question raises many issues.
Should you benchmark your portfolio versus an index like the S&P 500? What’s a fair comparison for a portfolio invested 65% equity / 35% fixed? What about an all-equity portfolio comprised of large-cap, small-cap, international, REITs and emerging markets?
Morningstar provides a quarterly list of average returns by category, which is a reasonable basic benchmark to measure a specific fund. For accounts using a diversified, multiple asset class approach, Morningstar provides returns for different asset allocation funds, sorted by equity ranges. This is a helpful guide should your portfolio be comprised of large-cap, small-cap, international and emerging market funds.
The Bottom Line
While an obsession with performance can be counterproductive (often leading to chasing past winners and inferior performance), an annual review of portfolio performance is something all investors should undertake. Make sure you understand what is being measured and how it is being measured so you can track progress toward your goals.
-
Stock Market Today: Dow Sinks 715 Points as Inflation Unrest GrowsInflation worries are showing up in both hard and soft data.
-
What the Senate's Vote to Repeal CFPB Bank Overdraft Fees Cap Means For YouThe Senate voted to overturn the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's cap on overdraft fees. Here's what you need to know.
-
Retiring With a Pension? Four Things to KnowThe road to a secure retirement is slightly more intricate for people with pensions. Here are four key issues to consider to make the most out of yours.
-
How to Teach Your Kids About the Tax Facts of LifeTaxes are unavoidable, so it's important to teach children what to expect. Also, does your child need to file a tax return for 2024? Find out here.
-
Revocable Living Trusts: The Good, the Bad and the UglyPeople are conditioned to believe they should avoid probate at all costs, but when compared with living trusts, probate could be a smart choice for some folks.
-
How to Plan for Retirement When Your Child Has Special NeedsWhen your child has special needs, your retirement plan should include a plan for when you'll no longer be able to care for them yourself. A five-step guide.
-
Tax Advantages of Oil and Gas Investments: What You Need to KnowTax incentives allow for deductions and potential tax-free earnings — benefits accessible only to accredited investors in small producer projects.
-
Charitable Contributions: Five Frequently Asked QuestionsMake the most of your good intentions by understanding the ins and outs of charitable giving. A good starting point is knowing what's deductible and what isn't.
-
Financial Leverage, Part Two: Don't Say We Didn't Warn YouA lesson in how highly leveraged investments can benefit the first movers and crush the next round of buyers.
-
Taxes in Retirement: What ESOP Participants Need to KnowMost Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOP) participants transfer company stock to an IRA starting around age 55, so taxes on that money have been deferred.
