Hedge Fund Managers' Stock Picks and Pans

Sell Moody's and Apollo. Take a flier on General Growth Properties. Those were some of the ideas that emerged in a New York City concert hall usually reserved for jazz acts. The setting was the Ira W. Sohn Investment Research Conference. The event, which is held for charity, invites accomplished hedge-fund managers to riff on the economy and tout investing ideas. Proceeds from the event go to groups that fight pediatric cancer and other illnesses.

The conference often attracts managers who rarely speak to the public. We attended the event, held on May 27, so you didn't have to. Exclusivity, however, does not guarantee great results. As Barron's notes in its current issue, the performance of nearly all the picks presented at last year's conference was dismal. Perhaps that explains why so few of last year's speakers came back for another go-around this year.

Only David Einhorn, of Greenlight Capital, managed to earn a return worthy of his pay. Last year, Einhorn told attendees to sell short shares of investment bank Lehman Brothers. Less than four months later, Lehman filed for bankruptcy. Anyone who acted on Einhorn's advice earned a return of nearly 100%.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

This year, Einhorn calls out bond-rating agencies. Specifically, he targets Moody's Corp. (symbol MCO), which Einhorn's hedge fund has sold short. Einhorn believes that bond ratings are "socially irresponsible products" and that the rating agencies' government-enforced oligopoly should end. He says that the raters downgrade companies only well after their credit problems are apparent and that triple-A ratings encourage companies to take on too much credit risk, what he calls "the curse of the triple-A rating." The curse plagued the likes of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and American International Group -- all formerly triple-A-rated companies and all now wards of the U.S. government. Moody's shares closed May 27 at $28.15.

Activist investor Bill Ackman, who is best known for his quest to get seated on Target Corp.'s board of directors, has taken a shine to a troubled owner of shopping malls. Ackman, whose hedge fund is called Pershing Square Capital Management, says he thinks General Growth Properties (GGWPQ.PK) will emerge from bankruptcy reorganization in a strong enough position to benefit investors daring enough to buy its shares.

Stockholders "can make a lot of money in a bankruptcy as long as the assets are worth more than the liabilities," Ackman says. General Growth's properties, which include more than 200 shopping malls in 44 states, are still generating plenty of cash, he says.

General Growth sought bankruptcy protection because it couldn't refinance its mortgages during the financial crisis, not because its business is unsound. Shares of the real estate investment trust closed at $1.31 on May 27. Ackman thinks the stock is worth $10 a share in a bankruptcy-court decision that does not involve liquidating the company -- his most pessimistic scenario -- and as much as $30 if court rulings favor General Growth.

Jim Chanos, of Kynikos Associates, the short seller who famously uncovered fraud at Enron in 2001, now has a bone to pick with for-profit educators and health-care companies. "There's a new sheriff in town," Chanos says, referring to President Obama. He thinks the administration views health care and education as rights that should be available to all citizens. Therefore, the government will squeeze profitability out of for-profit education and health-care companies.

Chanos is bearish on national for-profit educators, such as Apollo Group (APOL), owner of the University of Phoenix chain. And he says that Lincare (LNCR), which provides oxygen services to patients in their homes, is "the poster child" of the type of company that will suffer as the administration seeks to curb health-care costs. Apollo closed May 27 at $50.85 and Lincare closed at $22.60.

Although the hedgies spent considerable time discussing stocks, most speakers took the opportunity to present their decidedly bleak economic forecasts. The reliably bearish Peter Schiff, of Euro Pacific Capital, warned investors to "stay away from U.S. assets." Peter Thiel, of Clarium Capital Management, a co-founder of PayPal and an early investor in Facebook, says that innovation in the U.S. has stagnated for 40 years. He thinks energy-related investments will perform well because the U.S. won't be able to shake its addiction to oil.

David Sokol, chairman of MidAmerican Energy Holdings, a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway and one of a handful of men who is in the running to succeed Berkshire's Warren Buffett, was the only presenter who was not a hedge-fund manager. Sokol says that the housing market won't stabilize until 2011.

For the sake of better times ahead, let's hope that all of these gloomy calls are as accurate as the ones from last year's powwow.