Does your mutual fund play fair, giving the same rights to the little guys that it gives to big institutional investors? Does it have systems in place to ensure that fund officials don't violate securities rules and are paid based on performance? In other words, is your fund as careful with your cash as you are?
A new study suggests that paying attention to issues such as these is more than an academic exercise. Fund researcher Morningstar says its data confirm a link between how mutual funds treat clients and how well the funds perform. Morningstar has been calculating "stewardship" grades for funds since 2004, right after the industry was rocked by revelations that some funds had allowed big customers to break the funds' rules at the expense of smaller clients.
Laura Lutton, Morningstar's editorial director, says that more than 25% of the funds that received Ds and Fs in the initial set of ratings have since closed or merged -- both signs of failure. More than 80% of the funds that got grades of A and B in 2004 subsequently delivered above-average risk-adjusted returns. (Risk-adjusted performance typically compares a fund's returns with its volatility. A fund with, say, good returns and low volatility may have better risk-adjusted results than one with great returns and high volatility.)
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Funds with above-average risk-adjusted performance may not be the "hot" funds of the hour. But they're the kind of funds you can own for decades without regrets, says Lutton. Yet even she wouldn't pick a fund based on its stewardship grade alone. She considers the grade more of a tie-breaker.
The stewardship grade takes into account five factors:
1. Regulatory history (funds that break the rules get bad grades).
2. Fees (the lower the better).
3. Manager compensation based on performance.
4. The strength and independence of a fund's board of directors (and thus the value of the oversight it provides).
5. Investor-friendly rules and policies -- for example, whether the fund is willing to close to new investors before it gets too big.
How do the funds in the Kiplinger 25 rate on stewardship? Quite well, overall. Of the 17 funds with grades, eight received an A; none got a D or an F. (For comparison, just 9% of ranked funds overall received an A.) Below are more details on these scores.
| Dodge & Cox Stock | 6/22/2010 | A | B | A | A | B | A |
| Fidelity Contrafund | 12/22/2010 | C | C | C | C | B | A |
| Primecap Odyssey Growth | 11/11/2009 | A | A | A | B | B | A |
| T. Rowe Price Equity Income | 1/12/2011 | A | B | A | B | A | A |
| Vanguard Dividend Growth | 2/8/2011 | A | B | A | A | B | A |
| Dodge & Cox International Stock | 6/22/2010 | A | B | A | A | B | A |
| Fidelity Low-Priced Stock | 1/7/2011 | C | C | C | B | B | A |
| Harbor International | 11/9/2010 | B | B | A | A | D | A |
| T. Rowe Price Small-Cap Value | 1/13/2011 | A | B | A | A | A | A |
| Vanguard Selected Value | 2/10/2011 | B | B | A | A | C | A |
| Dodge & Cox Income | 6/22/2010 | A | B | A | A | B | A |
| Fidelity Intermediate Muni Income | 12/22/2010 | C | B | C | A | C | A |
| FPA Crescent | 3/4/2011 | C | B | A | F | C | A |
| Harbor Bond | 11/9/2010 | B | B | A | C | B | A |
| Harbor Commodity Real Return Strategy | 11/10/2010 | C | B | A | F | D | A |
| T. Rowe Price Emerging Markets Stock | 1/12/2011 | A | B | A | B | A | A |
| Vanguard Short-Term Investment-Grade | 2/10/2011 | B | B | A | A | D | A |
-
The Stoic Retirement: Ancient Wisdom for Today's RealityA "Stoic retirement" doesn't mean depriving yourself. It's a character-based approach to life and aging that can bring calm and clarity.
-
My Teen Crashed His Car and Now Our Insurance Has Tripled. What Now?Dealing with the costly aftermath of a teen car accident is stressful. Here are your options for navigating it.
-
11 Outrageous Ways To Spend Money in RetirementWhether you have excess cash to spend or want to pretend, here’s a look at 11 ridiculous ways retirees can splurge.
-
The 5 Best Actively Managed Fidelity Funds to Buy and Holdmutual funds Sometimes it's best to leave the driving to the pros – and these actively managed Fidelity funds do just that, at low costs to boot.
-
The 12 Best Bear Market ETFs to Buy NowETFs Investors who are fearful about the more uncertainty in the new year can find plenty of protection among these bear market ETFs.
-
Don't Give Up on the Eurozonemutual funds As Europe’s economy (and stock markets) wobble, Janus Henderson European Focus Fund (HFETX) keeps its footing with a focus on large Europe-based multinationals.
-
Vanguard Global ESG Select Stock Profits from ESG Leadersmutual funds Vanguard Global ESG Select Stock (VEIGX) favors firms with high standards for their businesses.
-
Kip ETF 20: What's In, What's Out and WhyKip ETF 20 The broad market has taken a major hit so far in 2022, sparking some tactical changes to Kiplinger's lineup of the best low-cost ETFs.
-
ETFs Are Now Mainstream. Here's Why They're So Appealing.Investing for Income ETFs offer investors broad diversification to their portfolios and at low costs to boot.
-
Do You Have Gun Stocks in Your Funds?ESG Investors looking to make changes amid gun violence can easily divest from gun stocks ... though it's trickier if they own them through funds.
-
How to Choose a Mutual Fundmutual funds Investors wanting to build a portfolio will have no shortage of mutual funds at their disposal. And that's one of the biggest problems in choosing just one or two.
