Much has been written about the new Department of Labor rule requiring most financial advisers be held to a “fiduciary” standard. Until the rule went into effect, a majority of financial advisers were legally held to a watered-down requirement requiring “suitability” of advice. Two questions come to mind:
- What is the difference between advice that meets the fiduciary standard and advice that’s merely suitable?
- How do I know if a fiduciary is truly acting as one?
The best way to explain the concepts is through examples. Frank is 65 years old, very conservative and concerned about stock market volatility. He owes $300,000 on his mortgage while paying interest at 4%. He has $400,000 in cash currently, $350,000 in an IRA account and wants to sell an older rental house for $300,000 with a potential income tax on the sale of $50,000.
A Broker/Dealer’s ‘Suitable’ Advice
First Frank seeks the advice of a broker held to the suitability standard. Sarah works for a very large national company based on Wall Street. She knows if she tells Frank to pay off his mortgage, she will lose potential business, and potentially her job. You see, since she is held only to a suitability standard, she owes her primary allegiance to the company she represents, not to the investor.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Instead of recommending that Frank pay off his mortgage, she instead brings out graphs showing how the stock and bond market has performed historically in an attempt to convince this person how investing in the market will be better than paying off a mortgage in retirement. In the end, a lot of pressure is applied for Frank to invest the cash, the IRA and the rental property proceeds net of tax into stocks and bonds. Sarah would invest the $1 million into loaded mutual funds where Frank is charged $57,500 in commissions on the first day.
Fiduciary Advice from 2 RIAs with 2 Different Opinions
Next, Frank seeks the advice of two different Registered Investment Advisers (RIA) held to the fiduciary standard. The first RIA suggests the same advice he heard from Sarah, but would invest in no-load funds so that Frank can avoid paying the commission. The second RIA suggests paying off the mortgage, and investing the rest into stocks and bonds. In each of the three meetings, Frank brought up the fear of rising interest rates and questioned whether bonds were the best investment solution. Each adviser responded similarly, citing long-term historical bond performance statistics.
Do RIAs held to the same standard sometimes offer completely different advice? The answer to this question is absolutely yes. This fiduciary standard of care isn’t always consistently applied. One problem with this standard is that if you sell stocks and bonds for a living, you may be convinced everyone needs stocks and bonds. If you sell annuities and not stocks, you may tell the world about how horribly volatile the stock market is and talk them out of investing in stocks and bonds.
A Final Piece of Fiduciary Advice with a Different Take
What might a better fiduciary solution look like here? Frank sought out the advice of an RIA who was also a CPA. The first piece of advice was to pay off that mortgage. The second piece was to get a home equity line of credit in case of a liquidity emergency. As for the rental house, instead of paying the income tax on the sale, a tax-deferred 1031 exchange was decided upon, reinvesting into a professionally managed apartment complex. Finally, a mix of stocks and a fixed indexed annuity was recommended as a bond substitute.
Frank saved on income taxes, improved cash flow, and has better growth potential without significantly adding to overall portfolio risk.
The Final Word: My Take on the Fiduciary Rule
I’m generally happy about the new DOL rule and its attempt to raise the bar within my industry. However, I don’t think the new rule goes far enough. How can an adviser truly offer the best advice if they aren’t licensed in — and fully understand — stocks, bonds, passive real estate, insurance products and federal tax law implications?
In the end, financial planning advice is based on the opinion of your adviser. Opinions vary between advisers based upon what they are familiar with, their licensing and experience. Opinions cannot be easily measured or compared.
So, even with a new set of standards within the industry, it’s still up to the consumer to perform their own due diligence when selecting the best financial adviser for themselves.
-
You Don’t Want to Retire in Portugal: Here Are Three Tax Reasons WhyRetirement Taxes With the NHR benefit retiring and pension taxes increasing, you might rethink your retirement plans in Portugal.
-
Home Depot's Winning Ways Fueled Its 100,000% ReturnHome Depot's wide moat leaves little room for competition – and shareholders have profited as a result.
-
Financial Pitfalls to Avoid in Your 30s, 40s and 50sAs you pass through each decade of working life and build wealth for retirement, watch out for the financial traps that can hinder your progress.
-
Five Key Retirement Challenges (and How to Face Them Head On)Life will inevitably throw challenges at you as you get older. But making a flexible retirement plan — and monitoring it regularly — can help you overcome them.
-
Four Action Items for Federal Employees With $2M+ SavedIf you can't stand the chaos, maybe you can walk off into the sunset of retirement. Here are some thoughts on how to figure out if that would work for you.
-
How to Help Accelerate Support for Women's EqualityIt's International Women's Day, and the theme this year is Accelerate Action. Here's how we can all pitch in to help drive gender parity.
-
How Tariffs Could Impact Affluent RetireesThe wealthier you are, the less price increases on groceries and cars will hurt you, but if markets dive or we enter a recession, that's a different story.
-
How to Help Shield Your Retirement From InflationPicking the right investments at the right time can help ensure inflation won't flatten your retirement savings. Here are some tips.
-
Six Steps to Simplify Your Estate for Your HeirsA simplified estate strategy will expedite the settlement of your estate after you're gone, lower audit risk, reduce costs and cut your beneficiaries' stress.
-
Three Actions to Protect Wealth Transfer Amid Tax UncertaintyHow should families plan to pass on their wealth amid ongoing uncertainty over estate taxes? Even if TCJA provisions are extended, they might still be temporary.
