Diversification is simple to understand. In the context of managing your portfolio, it is (simply) about investing in diverse securities so as to lower the risk of the portfolio. Ever since Nobel Prize winner Harry Markowitz wrote his seminal paper "Portfolio Selection" in 1952, finance professionals (and increasingly lay people) have understood that the true risk of an asset is its contribution to the risk of a portfolio.
In a recent survey run by my firm, Insight Financial Strategists, 41% of investors reported that they believe having their net worth in a single mutual fund is sufficient diversification. After all, even the most concentrated mutual fund typically has several dozen stocks. However, many mutual funds diversify within a single asset class in a single country, such as, large-company stocks in the U.S.
Others will concentrate their portfolio on a few securities, sometimes with very unfortunate results. For instance, between September 1, 2015, until November 17, 2015, the Sequoia fund (symbol SEQUX) lost 26.3% of its value largely due to its high concentration in a single stock, Valeant (VRX). Looking at the price evolution of VRX below, and knowing that SEQUX had more than 30% invested in VRX, it is not surprising that the mutual fund tumbled.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
In practice, diversification is hard to implement. There are many levels of diversification. Some of them are:
- by individual securities;
- by asset manager;
- by asset class; and
- by geography.
Ideally, an investor will want to diversify so that the various investments are not correlated with one another, have low correlation or even have negative correlation. For instance, according to data from portfolio analytics firm Kwanti, Goldman Sachs (GS) and JP Morgan (JPM) have an 89% correlation based on monthly returns. In other words, buying GS and JPM in the same portfolio only provides a low diversification value.
In another example, JPM and Walmart (WMT) have a negative correlation of -0.14%, based on monthly returns, according to data from Kwanti. I don't know that I would necessarily want to buy either JPM or WMT. However, this pair provides good diversification from one another.
Most of us end up investing in mutual funds and exchange-traded funds, not in individual securities. The same principle applies there. Having a single large cap mutual fund that tracks Standard & Poor's 500-stock index may not be sufficient diversification.
Sure, the S&P 500 ETF provides more than one security and is, therefore, diversified. But in general, most of the securities within a single asset class will be highly correlated with one another (such as with JPM and GS). With that, you would be protecting yourself against the risk inherent in any given company in the portfolio, but not against risks inherent to the asset class or other factors.
Ideally, you would want to be diversified across asset classes, across regions of the world and across asset managers. The following jelly bean chart from Schwab demonstrates the benefits of a wide diversification program: the ranking of the assets by performance changes seemingly randomly from year to year. A fully diversified portfolio is intended to avoid the peaks and valleys of individuals asset classes while providing a more middle-of-the-road return experience.
Is your portfolio diversified? A detailed analysis from a fee-only Certified Financial Planner can give you the full scoop on your portfolio and provide suggestions to mitigate the risks that you are exposed to. Like any other sound advice, apply it now, not later.
Chris Chen CFP® CDFA is the founder of Insight Financial Strategists LLC, a fee-only investment advisory firm in Waltham, MA. He specializes in retirement planning and divorce financial planning for professionals and business owners.
-
Exceptional Returns With Hybrid InvestingSponsored Whittier Trust’s internal investment team selectively partners with outside managers to yield higher returns. We call it our hybrid architecture. Our clients call it the best of both worlds.
-
Social Security Administration Warns of Massive Layoffs: What It Means to YouThe Social Security Administration is gearing up to layoff thousands of workers. Here’s how it can impact you.
-
Want to Hire a Financial Planning Firm? Five Questions to AskThe key to finding a financial planner who will do great work for you and your family is knowing what to look for during your search.
-
Five Top Insurance Scams to Watch Out ForScammers are always looking to take advantage of unsuspecting people, and insurance issues are prime targets. Here's how to avoid falling victim.
-
A Little-Known Tax Buster for Rich Retirees: Zero-Coupon DSTMaybe you've heard of using Delaware statutory trusts to defer taxes on real estate investments, but zero-coupon DSTs take those benefits a step further.
-
Once You Hit 55, Is the Stock Market Still Your Best Bet?If you're investing heavily in the twists and turns of the stock market in your 50s or 60s, you may be risking too much.
-
How Confident Are You in Your Retirement Plan? Find Out With This QuizOn a scale of 1 to 10, how confident are you in your retirement plan? This quick quiz will help you find out if it's on track, or whether it needs more work.
-
Scared About Climate Change? Change the Way You InvestClimate change is hitting the U.S. hard, and while positive action from the White House may now be unlikely, individuals can use their wallets to hit back.
-
The Retirement Mindset Shift: Deciding When to Ease Off RiskChanging gears from growth to protection isn't easy for some folks. How do you do it? And when?
-
Want to Sue a Client for Unpaid Fees? That Can Backfire on YouIn some cases, it'll work out better if you let it go instead of trying to force a deadbeat client, patient or customer to pay your bill.
