The future of the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule is in jeopardy under the Trump administration. As of the writing of this article, its implementation has been delayed, but the rule could be changed or even scrapped. What happens remains to be seen.
In a way, however, that doesn’t matter because the rule — designed to tighten up the legal and ethical requirements for those giving retirement advice — has already let the cat out of the bag. It has shed light on how financial professionals are compensated and the different standards by which they operate. There’s no doubt that many in the financial industry are hoping it will go away, quickly and quietly and with its tail between its legs.
But even if the rule is eventually written off (or just rewritten), the debate already has brought a lot of attention to the industry’s confusing payment structure. Which is a good thing.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Fees come to the forefront
A lot of investors look at their quarterly statements and, because they don’t see any fees being deducted, think they aren’t paying anything for the services they’re getting. That isn’t true, of course. All advisers have to be paid in some way. And the way they are paid determines their responsibility to their clients.
If the adviser is working for a brokerage firm, he or she gets a commission on the transactions they execute, and they are held to the suitability standard.
That means, for example, that if their client is looking for growth and is comfortable with a fair amount of risk, the broker will recommend a mutual fund that is “suited” to those conditions.
Will it be the best mutual fund for the client? Maybe. Is there a lower-cost mutual fund out there? Potentially. But under the suitability standard, there is no requirement for the broker to use the better or lower-cost mutual fund. It’s possible they will limit their choice to a fund family their firm wants them to use, and the client won’t even know there were alternatives.
The impetus for the fiduciary standard
The commission/suitability model is the oldest — and it worked pretty well for a long time. But then mutual fund companies started building in additional fees, and some started creating revenue-sharing agreements with brokerage firms. Often, consumers were paying more and getting fewer options. That was a big factor behind the DOL’s push to make the fiduciary standard a must for retirement advisers.
Under the fiduciary standard, advisers are required to put their clients’ best interests before their own needs or their firms’ needs. If the client wants a growth mutual fund, the adviser must pick the one they think is the absolute best fit and would have to be able to substantiate why — lower costs, higher returns or perhaps some other reason related to strategy or manager.
Those who are fee-only advisers will charge an hourly rate or a flat fee for their time. If they are fee-based, which is the most common approach for a fiduciary adviser, they will charge a fee based on a percentage of the amount of money in the portfolios they are directly managing. They do not receive a commission for the work they do.
The bottom line for investors
And that’s the important thing to remember when you’re choosing a financial professional: If you’re paying a commission, you’re not paying for advice — you’re paying someone to execute buy and sell orders for you. That person may be trying to do the best they can for their clients, but they can be stuck inside the rules of the broker-dealer they represent, and with a list of securities available to them that are profitable for the firm. In the fiduciary world, when you’re paying a fee, you’re paying someone to do the best thing for you, without an incentive to sell one product or another.
Because of the clamor both for and against the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule, many people know more about this topic than their advisers ever expected they would.
No matter what happens from here, consumers should use that knowledge to choose the best adviser for their individual needs. Whether that adviser works in the suitability model or fiduciary model, at least the public can go in with eyes open.
Kim Franke-Folstad contributed to this article.
-
Investing in Art: 10 Things You Should KnowSavvy collectors know that investing in art blends an eye for aesthetics with a head for business.
-
Five Retirement Myths vs the RealityBelieving these myths about retirement could set you down the wrong path. Separating fact from fiction can help you approach your retirement with confidence.
-
Want an Encore Career in Retirement? Consider These Seven StepsBurnout, a need for a change and/or a desire to stay engaged often propel people to start a new professional chapter. This is how you can do it.
-
How Federal Retirees Can Make SSFA Repeals Work for ThemFrom higher Social Security benefits to increased spousal and survivor benefits, federal employees have much to gain from the Social Security Fairness Act.
-
How to Avoid These Five Costly Tax Mistakes That Many Retirees MakeMaking incorrect assumptions about tax brackets, tax-loss harvesting, charitable giving, estate taxes and more can cost you big-time in retirement.
-
Are You a Baby Boomer With $500,000 or Less Saved for Retirement?Here are seven ideas Baby Boomers can consider to help make the most of their financial resources for retirement.
-
Social Security Fairness Act Adds to Pressure on Safety NetWhile the law seeks to level the playing field for many federal employees, the sustainability of the Social Security system is now facing even more challenges.
-
Four Ways to Financially Embrace the Year of the Wood SnakeIn the Year of the Wood Snake, consider looking to the snake's traits of being strategic, cunning and alert to help guide your finances this year.
-
Five Wins for Federal Employees in the Social Security Fairness ActMore money means more opportunities and financial stability for current retirees and future retirees.
-
How Do You Know Your Insurer Can Afford to Pay Your Claims?Here's how to find out where your insurance company stands financially and whether it has a good track record with customers.
