On Feb. 3, the Trump administration signed an executive order that may derail a rule that the Department of Labor (DOL) had planned to implement to help protect retirement savers. Briefly, rather than being forced to take on the role of “fiduciary” that the DOL rule would’ve demanded, this new directive will continue to allow brokers and certain types of advisors to place their own interests ahead of those of their clients.
Even though I’m a financial adviser who has acted in a strict fiduciary capacity for over two decades, I applaud this executive order. Here’s why:
SEC protections only extend so far
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is the main regulatory body responsible for monitoring advisers and ensuring that the investing public isn’t getting ripped off. The mission of the SEC is: “To protect investors, maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation.”
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Pretty clear, right?
As a principal in a registered investment advisory firm, I’m already regulated by the SEC and have a legal duty to operate as a fiduciary, which means I only make recommendations that are in my clients’ best interests.
That responsibility is something that I take very seriously.
If I were not registered with the SEC and, say, instead, was employed as a representative for a brokerage firm (like the ones affiliated with many of the large banks), I would instead be regulated by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
Basically, FINRA is an independent organization that does much of the regulatory work that would otherwise fall to the SEC.
The problem with ‘suitable’ investments
Why is this important? Because the entities that operate under the SEC’s Investment Advisor program are required to act as fiduciaries, while those that operate as brokers under FINRA’s jurisdiction need only offer products that are “suitable” for clients.
If you think the word “suitable” is too vague, you’re correct.
While the products offered by brokerage firms can be lousy, expensive and not in the best interests of their clients, just as long as they are deemed “suitable,” the broker is usually protected from liability.
For years I’ve been asking people “in-the-know” to explain to me why the SEC doesn’t do something to address this issue. It wouldn’t be difficult. They could require any financial adviser to act as a fiduciary, or they could create some clearer (and simpler) guidelines so that everyday investors can easily understand the differences.
For example, perhaps those individuals who sell commission-based investment products manufactured by their parent companies shouldn’t even be allowed to call themselves “advisers.”
DOL’s solution comes with a flaw
The fact is, the SEC, while having discussed this matter internally, has still done nothing to address the fiduciary issue.
This is why the Department of Labor acted. Part of the DOL’s mission is: “To foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners, job seekers, and retirees of the United States.” Given the fiduciary “vacuum” created by the SEC’s continued inaction, the DOL figured it would step in and try to protect the retirement plans of workers and retirees, alike.
One major shortfall of the DOL, however, is that it has no jurisdiction to regulate non-retirement accounts. Under this fiduciary rule, brokers would be required to act as fiduciaries only for IRA assets, but they could still continue to sell garbage to investors who have money outside of their retirement accounts.
While well-intentioned, the DOL rule gives investors a false sense of security, in my opinion. Simply, since the ruling, many of the people I’ve encountered had assumed that brokers and advisers were going to be required to act as fiduciaries in every instance.
The real fix that we need to protect consumers
Some people believe that any protection, no matter how limited or flawed, is enough. But I disagree.
What I would like to see is for the SEC to embrace its responsibility and enact a blanket fiduciary standard for anyone who calls themselves a “financial adviser.” This would protect the public and leave no ambiguity by ensuring that all advice rendered by financial advisers is always in the best interests of the client.
Until then, you can still protect yourself. For starters, ask your adviser if he/she is acting as a fiduciary in ALL circumstances. Are there times when they remove their fiduciary hat and put on the hat of a broker, earning commissions for products that are sold? Ask if there are ever times in the relationship where they are not legally required to act as a fiduciary. Finally, ask if they are willing to sign a fiduciary oath, such as the one found here: http://www.thefiduciarystandard.org/fiduciary-oath/.
The bottom line is that you want to make sure your advisor is working in your best interest, not in his or her own best interest.
Hanson's new book, Personal Decision Points, can be found on Amazon.
-
Dow Hits New Intraday High on Fed Day: Stock Market TodayNot even the most important stock in the world could keep the oldest equity index down on a significant day for markets.
-
Savings Goal CalculatorTools Want to know how much you need to save each month to reach your financial goals? Our calculator helps you build a realistic savings plan.
-
Gray Divorce Can Throw Your Retirement a Curveball: What to KnowIf you're entering retirement and going through a divorce at the same time, you've got some work to do to shore up your long-term financial security.
-
I'm a Real Estate Investing Expert: Optional 721 UPREIT DSTs Can Be the Best of Both WorldsBefore investing in any 721 UPREIT exchange, look for one that offers a straightforward, investor-friendly exit.
-
How an Expired Passport Thwarted Blackmail (and What Other Important Documents You Should Keep)An optometrist produced his expired passport to foil a blackmail attempt by the daughter of a former employee. After proving he was out of the country on the date of a forged diary entry, he took it a step further.
-
Optimize, Grow, Retain: The Power of Annual Client ReviewsFinancial advisers can use annual reviews to help enhance client outcomes, strengthen relationships and build their practice.
-
I'm a Real Estate Investing Pro: This Is What Investors Should Know About Truck Stop InvestmentsTruck stops might seem like good investments, but they can actually be a risky gamble due to unstable fuel prices, unreliable operators and coming changes in transportation. Instead, consider safer options like industrial or residential properties.
-
Don't Disinherit Your Grandchildren: The Hidden Risks of Retirement Account Beneficiary FormsStandard retirement account beneficiary forms may not be flexible enough to ensure your money passes to family members according to your wishes. Naming a trust as the contingent beneficiary can help avoid these issues. Here's how.
-
This Is How Life Insurance Can Fund Your Dreams NowBeyond a death benefit, life insurance can provide significant financial value and flexibility through 'living benefits' while you are still alive, helping with expenses like education, business ventures or retirement.
-
Potential Trouble for Retirees: A Wealth Adviser's Guide to the OBBB's Impact on RetirementWhile some provisions might help, others could push you into a higher tax bracket and raise your costs. Be strategic about Roth conversions, charitable donations, estate tax plans and health care expenditures.
