Every year when I update this popular column, I have another success story to tell of a parent who has managed to get holiday spending under control. This year's tale comes from a mom who wanted to tame her extended family's "somewhat ridiculous" tradition of requiring everyone to give gifts to all the children younger than 13.
She finally talked them out of the tradition, she says, "by laying down the law." "I'm pretty much the only one capable now of hosting the family Christmas gathering," she writes. "Because I have a newborn, I told everyone they'd have to do things my way if they wanted me to host. One of the things I requested was that the kids draw names among themselves and give one gift apiece. And I got no arguments from anyone. Yay! I won!"
I bet all of her relatives breathed a collective sigh of relief that someone had finally stepped up and called a halt to the madness. If your family similarly suffers from gift addiction and you'd like to break the habit, I'm happy to stage an intervention with my best advice on putting Santa on a budget:
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Don't feel obliged to buy your children everything they want (or feel guilty if you can't afford something because you're worried about your finances). If a toy or gift isn't in the cards, let the kids know upfront. They'll go along with your rules and your wishes as long as you make them clear and stick to them. If they have to go without -- or pay for something on their own -- it not only helps your pocketbook, but it also helps them develop a sense of personal responsibility.
Use wish lists to your advantage. Children need to learn to make choices, and what better tool to teach them than their annual holiday wish list? Once they've made their list, have them pare it down to, say, the top five things they want most. Or give them a dollar amount that they can't exceed.
Get Santa on your side. Tell your kids that Santa faces high demand with limited resources, so he needs a budget, too. Or come up with another creative comeback when kids hit you with the line, "I'll just ask Santa for it." Tell them that you and Santa are a team, and he's not about to go against your wishes by bringing a gift that you think is too expensive, too dangerous or not in sync with your family's values.
Pay with cash. That's one way to make sure Santa doesn't go overboard. Not only does paying with cash put an automatic cap on spending, but it also has a psychological effect: Brain research shows that it's actually more painful to buy with cash than with plastic.
In the same vein, one reader recommends giving kids gift cards. "Give them a set amount that you can afford and that limits how much they can spend. Beats all the holiday fuss -- lines, what to buy, size, etc."
It also has the advantage of giving children a lesson in money management. And I can attest that kids really do like gift cards; in my experience, they're less likely than adults to let them gather dust. (Hint: Web sites such as GiftCardGranny.com and PlasticJungle.com sell gift cards from popular retailers at discounts to their face value.)
Move beyond money by encouraging your kids to consider alternative holiday gifts. You (and they) could give thoughtful presents of time or service -- such as taking over a sibling's chores for a month, or giving Mom and Dad a tutorial in using their new smart phones.
And there's a bonus: Those kinds of personal gifts are a good hands-on way to teach kids the joy of giving. More on that in my next column.
P.S. Feel free to share your own strategies for putting Santa on a budget in the comment box below.
-
What the Comcast Cable Spinoff Means for InvestorsComcast has announced plans to spin off select cable networks and digital assets into a separate publicly traded company. Here's what you need to know.
-
TJX Stock: Wall Street Stays Bullish After EarningsTJX stock is trading lower Wednesday despite the TJ Maxx owner's beat-and-raise quarter, but analysts aren't worried. Here's why.
-
What Does Medicare Not Cover? Seven Things You Should KnowHealthy Living on a Budget Medicare Part A and Part B leave gaps in your healthcare coverage. But Medicare Advantage has problems, too.
-
The 50-30-20 Budget Rule: A Simple Way to Save MoneySaving Using the 50-30-20 budget rule is an easy way to save. It helps you prioritize saving while paying off debt.
-
How Our Family Fights InflationBudgeting Millennials typically spend more than other generations on certain expenses that have been increasing most rapidly. Here are some tips to cut your losses.
-
Gas Prices Around the WorldBudgeting Many world gas prices can make what Americans pay at the pump seem like a bargain. But not all.
-
What You Can Do About Medical DebtBudgeting Millions of Americans are awash in debt from medical care. If you’re one of them, we have your options, whether the bills are new or a collector is calling.
-
How to Motivate Kids to Savepersonal finance It's not easy teaching your child to save. Here are some ways readers have incentivized their kids to keep track of their finances.
-
What to Do When You Can’t Pay Holiday DebtBudgeting More Americans borrowed money to pay for holiday purchases and now the bill is due. Balance transfer cards offer a reprieve.
-
Is Budgeting Overrated?Budgeting Take it from a financial planner, not everyone needs a budget. In fact, sometimes a budget can distract you from the real solutions to your financial problems.
