Q. For many years, the PTA at my children’s public elementary school has raised money from parents, in tax-deductible donations, to supplement the school budget. The PTA’s foundation pays for teachers’ aides, field trips, music lessons, playground equipment and other things. Now our school district is proposing that these expenditures be severely limited because they put students at less-affluent schools at a disadvantage. Do you think a ban is fair?
A. This is a hot issue all over America, and there is no easy answer. The libertarian side of my brain says government has no right to tell parents how they may use their own money to benefit their children’s school, so an outright ban strikes me as unethical. But the socially progressive side of my brain (or my heart) acknowledges that this private funding exacerbates educational inequality to the detriment of our nation (in ill-prepared workers, welfare dependency and other problems).
School districts are dealing with this dilemma in many ways. Some have no restrictions on private gifts from parents, businesses and foundations. Some, such as affluent Montgomery County, Md., disallow gifts to pay for staff, classes and basic facilities that should be covered by public funds, but do allow gifts to pay for amenities such as a new scoreboard, landscaping, artificial-turf fields and playground equipment. (Some projects there cost as much as $1 million.) The county has a review panel that approves such projects, with a vague guideline that the amenity may not “foster or exacerbate inequity.”
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
A compromise I find appealing—now used in a number of places and being considered in many others—is allowing parents to raise money for their own school’s use (staffing included), but encouraging or requiring them to share some of what they raise with the PTAs of poorer schools nearby.
-
BJ's Wholesale Pops on Membership Fee Hike, Stock BuybacksBJ's stock is rallying Thursday after the warehouse club raised its membership fee for the first time in seven years and unveiled a big stock buyback program. Here's what you need to know.
-
Why Snowflake Stock Is Still a Buy After EarningsSnowflake stock is surging Thursday after cloud company beat expectations for its third quarter and raised its full-year outlook. Here's what you need to know.
-
Should All Student Debt Be Forgiven?student loans My favorite reform would be making the repayment of all student loans proportional to the borrower’s future earnings.
-
Should Lenders Mail Unsolicited Checks to Potential Borrowers?credit & debt When it comes to preying on weak credit risks, it looks like Wall Street is at it again.
-
Do Adult Children Have an Obligation to Support Needy Parents?savings Even if some siblings can afford to help more than others, no one should shirk the obligation to assist in some way -- financial or otherwise.
-
How Can the Approval Process for New Drugs Be Speeded Up?investing There are many reform proposals, including some from free-market think tanks.
-
Should Ethics Determine Who You Do Business With?Smart Buying Consumers seeking to do business only with ethical companies should ask these questions.
-
Should Colleges Use Collection Agencies for Overdue Student Bills?college Colleges have many potent options for getting students to square their accounts.
-
Hold Soda Makers to Account for Health Woes?Business Costs & Regulation A strong case can be made that it’s unethical for companies to target the very customers who shouldn’t be heavy consumers of a given product.
-
Ways to Protect Borrowers From Predatory Home Lendingreal estate Land contracts drain low-income communities of resources.
