Something close to an obituary for DEI — diversity, equity, inclusion — appeared in the Wall Street Journal on April 21, titled, “Diversity Goals Are Disappearing From Companies’ Annual Reports: Dozens of firms change what and how they report diversity initiatives; deleting the word ‘diverse’ or cutting whole sections.”
I have a confession to make. While, like most people, I’ve heard lots of bad stuff about DEI, I could not really explain what it is or how it is supposed to benefit our society. And I’m not alone. In fact, before writing this story, I phoned several lawyer friends and asked them to describe what DEI is.
No one could provide a clear answer, but I often heard, “It is reverse discrimination and punishes white people for being successful.”
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
So, to fill the gap in my own lack of understanding, I interviewed attorney Ann Thomas,
chief diversity and inclusion officer of the nationwide law firm Stinson LLP.
She is a dynamic lecturer for LearnFormula — a provider of continuing legal education podcasts — and explained what DEI is and how, sadly, it has been misinterpreted and, in effect, hijacked. Thomas firmly believes that DEI can accomplish a great deal of good for society when in the right hands.
I asked her for an operational definition of DEI, or how it should function. She said, “Dennis, the goal of DEI is the promotion, fair treatment and full participation of all people and especially groups that have historically been under-represented or subject to discrimination.”
Becoming aware of unconscious bias
“We all have unconscious bias,” she added, “mental shortcuts the brain creates to make quick decisions based on past information. These biases only become a problem when shortcuts inadvertently harm others.
For example, she noted, “The legal field traditionally relied on grades and school prestige to determine whether someone would be successful. But there is no direct correlation as the profession has changed. Lawyers also need leadership skills, emotional intelligence and the ability to pivot to meet the demands of a changing industry. One way that our firm has expanded the qualities we look for when hiring new lawyers is grit — the ability to overcome adversity is a necessary skill that has nothing to do with grades.”
DEI remedies limitations on access to opportunities and retention
A glaring example of limiting access to opportunity was discussed by Anna Papalia in her book, Interviewology: The New Science of Interviewing, which I reviewed in my March 12 column, Why Poor Job Interviews Hurt Both Employers and Job Seekers. Papalia pointed out, “HR consultants admit that women will typically ensure they check every criteria on a job description before applying, but men will apply if they meet around 60%. So, if you don’t include unnecessary criteria, then you can accommodate women who otherwise would be able to do the job.”
To Thomas, “a knowledgeable employer will eliminate criteria that just are not relevant to the job. But it's not enough to stop at recruiting; we have to ensure that employees have a pathway forward for career advancement that takes their unique challenges into consideration.”
Is DEI contrary to a society based on meritocracy?
Thomas was quick to note that one of the false arguments against DEI is that it enables people to get a job that they are not otherwise qualified for. “We have never really had a true meritocracy,” she maintained. “Social and economic class has a lot to do with advancement.”
Lyle Sussman, professor emeritus at the College of Business at the University of Louisville and a frequent contributor to this column, agreed: “The belief that America is racially color-blind is a fallacy. The belief that it may become racially color-blind is a Utopian dream.”
Why the uproar? Why do so many dislike DEI?
“I think there is an assumption that DEI will replace those in power with people who have not had power,” Thomas said, “but it isn’t about replacement. Instead, it is about expanding the pie. There is a lot of unnecessary fear that DEI lowers standards. But that’s false reasoning. More likely than not, it is because you are not the best candidate. You may not have the nuanced skills needed to succeed in today's environment.”
The real beauty of adding diversity
There is a concrete business aspect to DEI, as Thomas noted: “People want to be in the company of and have business relationships with those who are like them. That is the essence of affinity bias — another mental shortcut. Yet, the real beauty of adding diversity is that you are able to have a smarter team, innovate, avoid overlooking something that could be significant and expand the pie, which benefits everyone. Our law firm — like many businesses — has seen an increase in clientele and work because of the diversity of our teams. This is one practical benefit of DEI.”
So, is it time to prepare a casket for DEI? Thomas said she doesn’t think so.
Dennis Beaver practices law in Bakersfield, Calif., and welcomes comments and questions from readers, which may be faxed to (661) 323-7993, or e-mailed to Lagombeaver1@gmail.com. And be sure to visit dennisbeaver.com.
Related Content
-
Three Ways President Trump Could Impact the EconomyThe Letter Some of Trump's top priorities could boost economic growth, but others risk fueling inflation.
-
Average Health Care Costs by Age: Can You Afford It?Expect to pay more as you age. We've got solutions for how to cover these costs, which can exceed $1,000 per month in your 60s.
-
Will You Be Able to Afford Your Dream Retirement?You might need to save more than you think you do. Here are some expenses that might be larger than you expect, along with ways to ensure you save enough.
-
More SECURE 2.0 Retirement Enhancements Kick in This YearSaving for retirement gets a boost with these SECURE 2.0 Act provisions that are starting in 2025.
-
Saving for Your Emergency Fund: As Easy as 1-3-6An emergency fund that can cover six months' worth of expenses is far easier to build if you focus on smaller goals at first.
-
The Wrong Money Question to Ask After Trump's ElectionIf you're wondering what moves to make with a new president moving into the White House, you're being dangerously shortsighted. Here's what to do instead.
-
An Investing Plan for This Year: Doing Less Can Lead to MoreAchieve more when investing in 2025 by planning to work smarter, not harder. These three strategies can help put you on the right track and keep you there.
-
All About Six Types of Auto Insurance CoverageDo you know what your auto insurance policy covers? Here's a primer on some coverage categories, along with examples of how each type of coverage works.
-
Social Security and Medicare Funding: Is the Sky Falling?Social Security and Medicare are slowly running out of money, but what does that mean for the retirees counting on them? Actually, it's not all bad news.
-
What We Need to Do to Protect Retirees' Financial SecurityCognitive decline and aging in general put older retirees at risk of losing their financial security when they're the most vulnerable. What can be done?
