Amazon shoppers who are fans of the company's "try before you buy" program got a rude awakening when they tried to log into their accounts this month.
The brand posted a subtle notice at the top of the landing page that read, "Prime Try Before You Buy will end on 01/31/2025. Shop Amazon Fashion to find our full selection of fashion items." The notice offered little insight as to why the program was ending, but Amazon reps confirmed it's all part of CEO Andy Jassy's effort to cut down on costs at the company.
The company also cited the increase of AI technology that allows customers to better predict their fit sizes as a reason for shuttering the program. "Given the combination of Try Before You Buy only scaling to a limited number of items and customers increasingly using our new AI-powered features like virtual try-on, personalized size recommendations, review highlights, and improved size charts to make sure they find the right fit, we’re phasing out the Try Before You Buy option, effective January 31, 2025," Amazon reps told CNBC.
While Amazon attributes the decision to advancements in AI-powered sizing tools, the move also reflects a broader trend in retail. Many companies are reassessing the cost-effectiveness of free returns and try-before-you-buy programs, signaling a shift toward policies that prioritize profitability and sustainability.
Why retailers are ending free returns and try-before-you-buy programs
In recent years, several major retailers, including Macy’s, Abercrombie, J.Crew, H&M, Nordstrom and Amazon, have quietly begun rolling back their once-generous free shipping and return policies in an effort to cut costs and reduce logistical burdens. Some retailers charge a return processing fee unless customers opt to return items in-store, while others no longer accept returns on certain sale or clearance items.
One reason behind these policy changes is the rising cost of reverse logistics, the process of handling returned merchandise. Retailers have to cover shipping, inspection, repackaging and restocking costs, which can add up quickly, especially with high return rates in fashion and footwear.
As sustainability becomes a bigger focus, many brands are rethinking the environmental impact of free returns. Millions of returned items end up in landfills each year. Some companies are steering customers toward subscription-based clothing and accessory rental services, like Nuuly or Rent the Runway.
Try before you buy: Brands still offering the service in 2025
As anyone who doesn't fit the "traditional" retail body type knows, sometimes you just need to experience a product in real life to know if it's going to suit you. If that sounds like you, there are still a few online shopping options that allow you to get products delivered to your door before having to shell out the cash to ship them there.
Here are a few retailers still offering try before you buy programs:
Stitch Fix
Stitch Fix, which created its business model on the try before you buy concept, is still offering clothing delivery and styling services that are sent to your door without having to commit to a purchase.
Once you get your box of clothing delivered, you can try on the pieces and only pay for those you wish to keep. If you keep an item from the box, the $20 fee goes to paying for that item. If you keep nothing from the box, you have to eat the $20 fee.
Warby Parker
Warby Parker allows you to try on pairs of eyeglasses and sunglasses for free with free shipping included both ways. From there, you can decide which items you keep or which you want to order prescription lenses for, thanks to the ease of a pre-paid postage label included in your purchase.
Trendsend
Similar to StitchFix, Trendsend is another try before you buy styling service that costs $20. You start with an online quiz to help determine your preferences. Try on the items sent to you, and choose to keep or send them back. The $20 goes towards any items you purchase, and the cost is eaten if you buy nothing. However, the first trial styling box is just $1.
Strategies for smarter online shopping
As free returns become less common and shopping evolves, these tips can help you adapt and get the most out of online shopping:
- Try it on Virtually. Many brands, like Sephora and Walmart, offer AI-driven virtual try-on technology that allows customers to see how makeup, glasses, shoes or clothing might look before committing to a purchase. While not perfect, these tools can help reduce the chances of buying the wrong item.
- Prioritize retailers with generous return policies. While many companies are introducing return fees, some still offer free in-store returns or longer return windows. Checking a brand’s return policy before making a purchase can save money and frustration.
- Use size recommendation apps. Try using a platform like True Fit or Fit Analytics to help ensure a better fit. These tools analyze past purchases and customer feedback to provide personalized size suggestions.
While free returns and try-before-you-buy options are becoming less common, taking advantage of virtual tools and carefully reviewing retailer policies can help ensure a smoother shopping experience with fewer returns.
RELATED CONTENT
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Are Mixed Before Liberation DayMarkets look forward to what comes with the reordering of 80-year-old global trade relationships.
-
Stagflation: What It Is and Why Retirees Should CareStagflation — the economic bogeyman of the 1970's — may return to the US. Here's what it could mean to your retirement.
-
Kohl’s to Close 27 Stores in March 2025 — Is Your Location on the List?Kohl’s is closing 27 stores this Saturday as part of its 2025 restructuring plan. Find out which locations are affected and why they’re closing.
-
Costco’s 4.5-Pound Tiramisu Cheesecake Might Be Your New Favorite DessertIf you haven’t visited your local Costco bakery to check out the Kirkland Signature Tiramisu Cheesecake, you'd better get there early, they are flying off the shelves.
-
Klarna Buy Now, Pay Later Is Coming to a Walmart Checkout Screen Near YouHow buy now, pay later options at Walmart could get easier after the retailer traded Affirm for Klarna.
-
Costco Spring Sale: Top Deals on Electronics, Furniture and MoreSpring savings have arrived at Costco. Shop major markdowns on furniture, electronics, appliances and more.
-
Is a "My Best Buy" Membership Worth It?We break down the perks, pricing and potential savings to help you decide if it’s a smart buy.
-
Wealthy Shoppers Love Walmart – And It’s Not Just About Cheap GroceriesWalmart’s faux luxury brands, convenient online shopping and widening selection are bringing in more high income consumers.
-
How I Scored Huge Savings on High-End Items with Costco Direct — Delivered Straight to My DoorDiscover how Costco Direct offers exclusive online deals, bulk-buying discounts, and direct-to-home shipping on furniture, appliances and more.
-
I Resolved to 'Shop My Closet.' Here's How It's Going"Shop your own closet" has been a call to look at what you already own rather than buy new things. An editor tries it out.
