Why I'm Keeping My Amex Gold Card Even With a Higher Annual Fee
If you have an Amex Gold Card, the new fee will be charged on your card anniversary date, starting October 1.
Disclaimer
Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Our relationship with advertisers may impact how an offer is presented on our website. However, our selection of products is made independently of our relationship to advertisers. Rate and fees updated as of September 20, 2024.
American Express announced major changes to its popular American Express® Gold Card recently, sending shockwaves through the credit card fanatics community (yes, that exists). If you are a current cardholder, you should decide to keep or cancel the card soon.
Based on its annual fee, the Gold is something of a mid-tier card — it's not a no-fee everyday card, but it's also not the Platinum Card, which has a whopping annual fee of nearly $700. The Amex Gold Card is a rewards credit card popular for the valuable points you can rack up via restaurants and grocery shopping and convert into flights and hotel stays.
In fact, Kiplinger rates it as one of the best travel rewards credit cards, based on the ease with which you earn points and their value when you use them. I myself am a Gold Card user and evangelist; a bulk of my spending is on food anyways, and I used Amex points from that spending to pay for my honeymoon flight to New Zealand.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
But I also recognize that Amex Gold has some drawbacks, primarily that I can use it to book travel, but then struggle to use it on my travels because many stores and restaurants abroad don't accept American Express cards. Because of that, I also have other credit cards to use.
So when American Express notified Gold Card customers recently that the annual fee was going up, I paused for a moment to consider if I should keep it. Here's how I thought about that fee increase.
Is the Amex Gold Card still worth it after the membership fee increased?
The annual fee for the American Express Gold Card is now $325, up from $250. For existing customers, the new annual fee will take effect on a rolling basis beginning on the Card Members’ annual renewal date starting October 1, 2024. If you decide it's not worth the additional $75, you must cancel the card at least 30 days before your annual membership fee is due (on your cardholder signup anniversary). See rates and fees.
But in addition to the new membership fee, Amex announced the Gold Card has some new perks. Based on my very basic calculations, these perks easily offset the new membership fee — arguably even better than before.
When I consider offsetting the membership fee, I think in pure dollar signs: Taking points out of the equation, what cash do I get back in return for the membership fee?
The new Gold Card perks include:
- $7 back monthly after paying with the card at a Dunkin'
- $50 back every six months after paying with the card at "Resy restaurants"
Now, add those to the existing perks, which are continuing:
- $10 back monthly in a dining credit when you use the card at "participating partners" that include Grubhub, The Cheesecake Factory, Goldbelly, Wine.com and Five Guys (note: Milk Bar and Shake Shack were previously eligible, but no longer are)
- $10 added to your Uber account monthly
You can also get a $100 "experience/property credit" if you book two or more nights with The Hotel Collection through AmexTravel.com, but personally speaking, I'm not always sure it's easy to use hotel credits or if I'd just be spending for the sake of using the $100 in credits. But if, say, you love hotel room service and would be spending money on that whether you were given a credit or not, factor that into your own decision tree.
I've found that the two credits above, in particular, are easy to use. I order from Grubhub at least once a month, so I get that $10, which comes in the form of a credit on my Amex statement every month. Meanwhile, the Uber credit is deposited directly and automatically into my Uber account. I don't have a car, so I tend to use Uber at least once a month, making use of that $10 directly. If you don't use Uber rides a lot, the credit can also be used for Uber Eats, so maybe if you order food twice a month, one time you use Grubhub and one time you use Uber Eats; there's your $20 from Amex.
So, on a very basic dollar-to-dollar basis, is the new membership fee worth it? Check my math on annual costs and returns:
Terms | Old Version | New Version |
---|---|---|
Grubhub (Dining) Credit | $120 | $120 |
Uber Credit | $120 | $120 |
Dunkin Credit | $0 | $84 |
Resy Creidt | $0 | $100 |
Total Credits | $240 | $424 |
Less Annual Fee | $250 | $325 |
TOTAL (PERKS - FEE) | - $10 | + $99 |
Based on these calculations, the previous membership fee and the perks it provided left me at a net negative of $10 (I received $240 annually on a $250 annual fee). Now, the new $325 membership fee would leave me with a net positive of $99 (I receive $424 annually on a $325 annual fee), making it a huge improvement.
But that equation comes with some caveats.
First, this is assuming you spend at least $10 via Uber every month, as previously discussed, and purchase something from Grubhub or the other participating "dining credit" options at least once a month.
Next, there's the Resy credit. Resy is a website and app you can use to make reservations at restaurants. At least where I live, in New York City, Resy is fairly widespread, with many restaurants using it as their primary way of making reservations. To get this Amex Gold Card credit, you actually don't even need to use Resy, you just need to pay at a restaurant that uses Resy. Again, I appreciate that simplicity. But, if you avoid eating out at restaurants or live in a place where Resy isn't very common, you may miss out on this reward.
Then, this assumes you buy something at Dunkin' every month. For me personally, Dunkin' is not part of my regular routine, so there might be some months I miss out on this credit. But even if I were to not get Dunkin' at all in a calendar year, I'm still up a net positive $15 on the annual membership fee.
Please also note that you have to "enroll" to get some of these rewards, which basically means you have to click a button to say you want it.
Here's a summary of the new perks and the welcome offer.
Annual fee: $325
Welcome offer: The card just sweetened its welcome offer for those wanting a lucrative dining and travel card. Earn up to 60,000 points if you spend $6,000 in the first six months. (Kiplinger estimates that Amex points are worth between one and two cents, meaning this welcome offer is worth about $600 to $1,200 when redeemed for travel.) Plus, receive 20% back in statement credits on eligible purchases made at restaurants worldwide within the first six months of Card Membership, up to $100 back. This is a limited-time offer. Offer ends 11/6/24.
Earning points: Earn four points for each dollar spent on the first $50,000 of restaurant purchases worldwide each year, then earn one point per dollar on restaurant purchases for the rest of the year. And earn four points per dollar spent at U.S. supermarkets (up to the first $25,000, then earn one point per dollar). The card also provides additional perks for using your card at many chains and restaurants.
Redeeming points: The most lucrative way to redeem points is for airfare booked through AmexTravel.com, or transfer them to hotel or airline partner programs. Though you can use points to pay for purchases at many retailers, such as Amazon and PayPal, the conversion rate is only 0.7 cents per point.
Interest rate: Pay Over Time APR: 20.74% to 28.74%, based on your creditworthiness and other factors as determined at the time of account opening.
Terms apply.
What else does the Amex Gold Card get you?
Now, what I did here was just a basic dollar-to-dollar calculation of what you get from the Amex Gold Card. But the card offers more.
First, the Gold Card periodically provides limited-time "offers" that give money back or accrue additional points if you shop at certain stores throughout the year. Make sure to keep an eye on the "Offers" tab on the American Express app, as you have to "enroll" for those, too.
Finally, there are those points. You earn them just by going through your daily life and you can use them to book flights and hotels. I'm always a little wary of the rates you get through the booking portal, but you can also transfer points to hotel or airline partner programs and then book directly. I'm not nearly as savvy at points tricks as others, but I can't deny that it is a really nice feeling to let the points pile up and then book a flight to the other side of the world for $0.
If you are not already a Gold Card user, of course there's a welcome bonus for new credit cardholders. There is a limited-time offer of 60,000 points after you spend $6,000 on the card in the first six months of having it, plus 20% back on restaurants in the first six months up to $100. There's also a white-gold option of the card now, if you're into that kind of thing.
I would tell you if the numbers didn't pass the sniff test here, but for me at least, the new perks are fairly easily offsetting the increased membership fee. At the end of the day, it comes down to your own lifestyle. If you'd be going out of your way to get Dunkin' or spending more on takeout just for the sake of the monthly credit, it might not be worth it. Do the simple math for yourself and see what makes sense.
Related Content
Disclaimer
As an independent publication dedicated to helping you make the most of your money, the article above is our view of the best deals and is not the opinion of any entity mentioned such as a card issuer, hotel, airline etc. Similarly, the content has not been reviewed or endorsed by any of those entities.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Alexandra Svokos is the senior digital editor of Kiplinger. She holds an MBA from NYU Stern in finance and management and a BA in economics and creative writing from Columbia University. Alexandra has a decade of experience in journalism and previously served as the senior editor of digital for ABC News, where she directed daily news coverage across topics through major events of the early 2020s for the network's website, including stock market trends, the remote and return-to-work revolutions, and the national economy. Before that, she pioneered politics and election coverage for Elite Daily and went on to serve as the senior news editor for that group.
Alexandra was recognized with an "Up & Comer" award at the 2018 Folio: Top Women in Media awards, and she was asked twice by the Nieman Journalism Lab to contribute to their annual journalism predictions feature. She has also been asked to speak on panels and give presentations on the future of media and on business and media, including by the Center for Communication and Twipe.
-
Adoption Tax Credit 2024: What You Need to Know
Tax Credits The federal adoption tax credit is slightly higher for 2024. Here’s what you can claim under the tax break designed to help grow your family.
By Gabriella Cruz-Martínez Published
-
Start-ups Trying to Solve the World’s Hardest Problems
The Letter More investors are interested in companies working on breakthrough science to tackle huge societal challenges. The field of deep tech has major tailwinds, too.
By John Miley Published
-
The Minimum Savings You Need To Retire in All 50 States
Are you concerned you haven't saved enough for retirement? Here are the average annual expenses and minimum savings amounts needed to get by in all 50 states.
By Donna LeValley Published
-
Three Tips for Managing Your Election-Related Stress
As Election Day approaches fast, consider taking some steps to keep your anxiety and expectations under control.
By Dennis D. Coughlin, CFP, AIF Published
-
Your Kid Is a New Driver: Will Your Car Insurance Take a Hit?
Most likely, but you can try to lessen the blow by asking about discounts and teaching your child as much as you can before they get their license.Karl
By Karl Susman, CPCU, LUTCF, CIC, CSFP, CFS, CPIA, AAI-M, PLCS Published
-
Honda Recalls 720k Vehicles Over Risk of Fuel Leaks
Following the Honda recall over a steering issue earlier this year, the carmaker has announced measures to find and replace faulty fuel pumps in some of its most popular models.
By Charlotte Gorbold Published
-
Seven Financial Mistakes to Avoid in Divorce
From overlooking hidden assets to scary tax surprises, help protect your financial future by steering clear of these common pitfalls during the divorce process.
By Julia Pham, CFP®, AIF®, CDFA® Published
-
How an Irrevocable Trust Could Pay for Education
An education trust can be set up for one person or multiple people, and the trust maker decides how the money should be used and at what age.
By Denise McClain, JD, CPA Published
-
How to Maximize Your Credit Card Rewards
Your cash back, points or miles may be worth hundreds — or even thousands — of dollars each year, if you know the best ways to earn and use them.
By Laura Petrecca Published
-
How to Change Financial Advisers
Before firing your financial adviser, here are a few things to prepare for.
By Kim Clark Published