“Mr. Beaver, I manage one of the largest machine shops in the Midwest and work with some of the brightest, most intelligent people on the planet. A machinist must have a superior knowledge of mathematics, and logical thinking is absolutely necessary,” “Tony’s” email began.
“However, skepticism is not a job requirement, and that is painfully true with ‘Will,’ who is the victim in a catfishing scam. He is 55, single, lonely, and his social — dating — skills are minimal due to him being terribly shy. He met a ‘lady(?)’ on (a dating) website, and over the past year, we all can see that she doesn’t exist, yet Will is sending her money. Each time they arrange to meet, something comes up, and she can’t make it. He is a scam victim, and nothing we say deters him from sending even more money! Have you got any ideas?”
'How stupid can you be?'
I ran the question by Orlando-based Chris Hadnagy. He is a recognized world-leading social engineer, author of Human Hacking (Harper Business, 2021), speaker and adjunct professor at the University of Arizona. He had several suggestions, beginning with what not to say or do.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
1. Don’t say, “You have fallen for what is obviously a scam! How stupid can you be? Obviously, they are not a real person.”
This approach will not work, as you are insulting the person. They have a lot of shame already and are feeling protective of this relationship. Now you have just called them out, and no one likes to be called out on a perceived shortcoming. Plus, sometimes when we tell someone to not do something, they want to do it more.
2. Don’t contact the suspicious person on the side and threaten, “If you don’t leave my mom (or my friend) alone, you’ll regret it!”
Sending various threats is not a good idea, as that person will contact their victim and say, “Why did your boss say that he was going to hurt me? What’s going on between you two?”
So, now the scammer will use that as an opportunity to alienate the family and friends even more, saying things like: “They don’t understand our relationship.” “They don’t get it!” “I don’t want them reaching out to me like that ever again!”
3. Don’t print out articles about romance scams to show the victim. That rarely works, and it often makes them even more determined to protect the scammer.
Even though there is the objective, intellectual proof they are just like the people in the articles, all reasoning is abandoned — they refuse to accept it — due to what psychologists call the commitment and consistency principle. “When our brains commit to something, we hate to be inconsistent and will look for proof that we are right and exclude proof that we are wrong. Our brains do not like things that are inconsistent. It feels bad.
So, when this person is committed to “the love of my life, I believe it,” and if you show them a bunch of articles, they will reply, “I’m sorry those people fell for a scam, but that’s not me.”
Here's what can work
So instead of doing the above three things, you can encourage your loved one to obtain verification that the person they are dealing with is real. Ask them, “Have you done any video calls? Have you ever talked with her live, a chat where you can see each other?” Often, the response is that they have not, so you then say, “Why not get on the phone with them before sending any more money?”
As long as you sound concerned, they will likely not become defensive. However, anyone in a stage of infatuation is not necessarily thinking critically. So, using sound reasoning with them might not be successful. You might then ask, “If this is the love of your life, don’t you want to meet her in person? Meet her friends and family? Maybe you should plan a trip to see her or fly her here for a visit.”
Warn your loved one to be on guard against excuses such as “my webcam is broken.”
Another approach would be to ask, “If you had a son or daughter in the same situation as you are now, what would you want them to do just to be sure that the person really exists?”
Hadnagy concluded our interview with this advice for loved ones of romance scams:
- As we do with kids when we warn them about strangers and drugs, talk with your older family members about being wary of people reaching out and being extra nice, in case all they really want is money.
- Request that they let you know if a stranger starts chatting them up. That way, you can look into it before a scam can take root.
- Do not make older people feel stupid, or they will refuse to come to you for advice.
Hadnagy also provided this advice for potential scam victims:
- If you are getting wonderful emails and calls from someone who found you online, go to the people you trust and ask them, “What do you think about this?” And really listen to what they tell you.
- If you have sent money and realize afterward that it is a scam, report it to law enforcement before you end the relationship, as the police might be able to set up a sting and apprehend them.
To learn more about Hadnagy’s social engineering expertise, I recommend visiting his website, www.social-engineer.com.
Dennis Beaver practices law in Bakersfield, Calif., and welcomes comments and questions from readers, which may be faxed to (661) 323-7993, or e-mailed to Lagombeaver1@gmail.com. And be sure to visit dennisbeaver.com.
Related Content
-
Stock Market Today: Dow Pops 703 Points on Cooler InflationA benign reading from the Consumer Price Index report assuaged market fears about the path of borrowing costs.
-
CPI Report Keeps the Fed on Track: What the Experts Are Saying About InflationCPI Disinflation in key areas of consumer prices should help the Federal Reserve stick to its policy path of gradual cuts to interest rates.
-
Stock Market Today: Dow Pops 703 Points on Cooler Inflation
A benign reading from the Consumer Price Index report assuaged market fears about the path of borrowing costs.
-
CPI Report Keeps the Fed on Track: What the Experts Are Saying About Inflation
CPI Disinflation in key areas of consumer prices should help the Federal Reserve stick to its policy path of gradual cuts to interest rates.
-
Why Wells Fargo's Revenue Miss Isn't Worrying Wall StreetWells Fargo is one of the best S&P 500 stocks Wednesday even after the big bank's top-line miss. Here's what you need to know.
-
Citigroup Stock Jumps on Earnings, $20 Billion Stock Buyback NewsCitigroup stock is soaring Wednesday after the big bank topped earnings expectations and unveiled a massive stock buyback program. Here's why that's important.
-
Is JPMorgan Chase Stock a Buy, Hold or Sell After Earnings?JPMorgan Chase is trading higher after the big bank topped fourth-quarter earnings expectations, but is the stock a Buy? Here's what you need to know.
-
Generational Wealth Plans Aren't Just for Rich PeopleEverybody needs to consider what will happen to whatever assets they have and ensure their beneficiaries aren't stuck with big tax bills.
-
To Insure or Not to Insure: Is Life Insurance Necessary?Even if you're young and single with no dependents, you may need some life insurance. Here's how to figure out what and how much you may need.
-
How Another Trump Presidency Will Impact the Stock Market in 2025President Trump will have little direct impact on the stock market, but his policies, initiatives and posts certainly can make prices move. Here's how.
