Rising Interest Rates, Falling Bonds and a Possible Way Forward
Bonds aren’t offering the stability they used to, so if you’re looking for an alternative, here’s one possibility to consider.


As interest rates rise, are you wondering if the bonds in your portfolio are still the wise investment you once thought?
If you are having second thoughts about bonds, you aren’t the only one. In the latter part of 2021, even Bill Gross, known as the “Bond King,” said that bonds belong in the “investment garbage can.”
Bonds typically have an inverse relationship with interest rates, meaning when interest rates rise, bond values decrease. With interest rates currently rising, plenty of people are wondering what they can put in their portfolio in exchange for bonds.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
For many years, bonds provided something of a safe haven to balance the risk portion of a portfolio, especially for those approaching retirement. For example, if your mix was 60% stocks and 40% bonds, what should you do with that 40% if bonds no longer provide the security and stability they once did? Some adjustments may be in order, but how do you get growth potential without assuming too much risk?
One possibility is a fixed-indexed annuity (FIA). People often think of an annuity as something that pays a guaranteed fixed amount of monthly income for your lifetime, much like a pension. This can be the case, but it also can be restrictive because once the amount of income is fixed, it is unlikely that it can be changed.
However, there are FIAs that are focused on accumulation (i.e., growing your money) rather than providing guaranteed income. Investing in this manner means you don’t have to lock into a fixed monthly withdrawal, but rather you generate retirement income by withdrawing gains and/or principal. This is much like withdrawing from a traditional stock and bond portfolio by using dividends and gains to create income. The major advantage is that the principal and gains are protected and cannot decrease, unlike bonds. Factors such as the economy, stock market declines, etc., will not create losses within these types of annuities.
That’s one of the great things about annuities — their upside is potentially growing when markets are up (with limitations), but when the markets go down, FIA values stay put. This eliminates risk and makes FIAs a good option for those seeking a bond replacement. Two studies do an excellent job of making this point, each explaining in detail a potential way forward for investors looking for that portfolio alternative.
Annuities and Bonds: The Very Long View
Let’s look at one of those studies. A few years ago, economist Roger Ibbotson researched nearly a century’s worth of market results to create a hypothetical model comparing how FIAs would have fared against bonds from 1927 to 2016. Remember that 1927 is a couple of years before the 1929 stock market crash that carried us into the Great Depression.
What he and his team of researchers found is that, net of fees, FIAs had an annualized return of 5.81%, compared with 5.32% for long-term government bonds and 9.92% for large-cap stocks in this period of both rising and falling yields.
In some years when the bond yields were especially low, a FIA would have helped investors even more, Ibbotson found. In other words, a 60/40 stock and bond mixture was good; a 60/20/20 mixture of stocks, bonds and annuities was better; and a 60/40 mix of stocks and FIAs was best of all.
A more recent study by BlackRock corroborated Ibbotson’s findings with three main conclusions:
- Adding FIAs to a portfolio added greater upside potential in more average stock market return years.
- FIAs improved outcomes in balanced portfolios during extremely bad market years.
- Incorporating FIAs can provide more certainty around future portfolio values in general.
BlackRock pointed to the importance of sequence of return risk, which is how the order of investment returns affect a portfolio when withdrawals are being taken. If no withdrawals are being taken, the order of returns does not matter. But when distributions are being taken, early losses can have a devastating impact on a portfolio’s longevity, whereas those same losses later would not be so detrimental. By using FIAs as a bond replacement, BlackRock found better long-term outcomes because the FIAs protected against potential losses early in retirement.
BlackRock further mentioned that some investors have high cash positions to avoid potentially selling out of the market during a loss. They suggest that the FIA is a good cash replacement because it “retains its ability to guard against negative outcomes, while providing a sizable increase in potential upside capture.”
Figuring Out What’s Best for You
What should you do if you want to consider an alternative to the bonds in your portfolio? Making the best decision for your situation is especially important if you are in the “Retirement Red Zone” — the five-year period on either side of retirement. That’s a period when protecting what you’ve accumulated throughout years of saving and investing should be a priority. As the sequence of return risk shows, a big loss in that time span can be disastrous for the rest of your retirement.
Maybe you will decide to keep some money in bonds after all, or that you don’t want to give up on that 60/40 split (or whatever you have) because it’s what you’ve known all these years. Perhaps you go with the 60/20/20 mix, edging slightly out of bonds but not completely. Or, maybe you decide to ditch bonds altogether to see what fixed-indexed annuities hold for you.
Ultimately, it will be your call, but your financial professional should be able to provide information and advice that will help you weigh the options in a more informed manner.
That way you can enter retirement with more confidence — and with a better chance of achieving the secure future you seek.
Ronnie Blair contributed to this article.
Disclaimer
The appearances in Kiplinger were obtained through a PR program. The columnist received assistance from a public relations firm in preparing this piece for submission to Kiplinger.com. Kiplinger was not compensated in any way.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Kurt Fillmore is founder and president of Wealth Trac Financial, an independent financial services firm based in Bingham Farms, Michigan, specializing in customized wealth management and retirement planning. He is an Investment Adviser Representative and licensed insurance professional.
-
Are You a Retirement Millionaire Too Scared To Spend?
If you are too scared to spend money in retirement, you may be saddled with regret. Here are three ways to safely enjoy your sizable retirement nest egg.
By Donna Fuscaldo Published
-
U.S. Treasury to Eliminate Paper Checks: What It Means for Tax Refunds, Social Security
Treasury President Trump signed an executive order forcing the federal government to phase out paper check disbursements by the fall.
By Gabriella Cruz-Martínez Published
-
Seven Questions to Ask When Evaluating Personal Loan Options
Taking out a personal loan too hastily could lock you into unfavorable terms with an untrustworthy lender. Ask these questions before signing anything.
By David Kimball Published
-
The Three Biggest Fears Keeping Retirees Up at Night
Here are the steps you can take to put those fears to rest and retire with confidence so you can relax and enjoy the life you've planned.
By Pam Krueger Published
-
What Can a Donor-Advised Fund Do for You? (A Lot)
DAFs and private foundations go about helping charities (and those who donate) in different ways. Each comes with its own benefits and restrictions to navigate.
By Julia Chu Published
-
Estate Planning When You Have International Assets
Estate planning gets tricky when you have assets and/or beneficiaries outside the U.S. To avoid costly inheritance mistakes, it pays to understand the basics.
By Kelsey M. Simasko, Esq. Published
-
Three Essential Estate Planning Steps to Protect Your Nest Egg
After dedicating years to building your wealth and securing your future, make sure your assets are protected and your loved ones are provided for in the future.
By Nicole Farbo, CFP® Published
-
Is Chasing the American Dream Ruining Your Financial Life?
Too many people focus on visible affluence as a marker of success. Here's how to avoid succumbing to the pressure and driving yourself into debt.
By Anthony Martin Published
-
Retiring With a Pension? Four Things to Know
The road to a secure retirement is slightly more intricate for people with pensions. Here are four key issues to consider to make the most out of yours.
By Joe F. Schmitz Jr., CFP®, ChFC® Published
-
How to Teach Your Kids About the Tax Facts of Life
Taxes are unavoidable, so it's important to teach children what to expect. Also, does your child need to file a tax return for 2024? Find out here.
By Neale Godfrey, Financial Literacy Expert Published