This common question comes from those who are fortunate enough to have the flexibility to decide. The reality is that the date is often a compromise between you and your employer. A combination of that employer’s benefits, as well as IRS rules, should help you decide which day makes the most sense for you. In today’s article, we are going to cover three options and the potential benefits that come with each.
July 31
As a general rule, the end of the month is good for those with pensions, as those often start on the first day of the month after retirement. In this scenario, retiring on the 31st means that you won’t have a gap in pay.
The midyear strategy has to do with condensing all income into one calendar year so that you’ll see a drop in taxes the following year. This could be accomplished on December 31 if it weren’t for the lump sums that are often paid out in the months following your retirement. This may include bonuses, commissions, unpaid vacation and sick leave.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
If you see a significant drop in your tax bracket in the following year, you should evaluate Roth conversions and capital gains recognition. This is a tax sale.
December 31
As above, December 31 has the benefit of a full month of income with the pension starting the next day. This is a common date for federal employees, who are the kings and queens of gaming the retirement system. Retiring on December 31 is likely to maximize your unpaid annual leave check.
There’s a drawback, though: That lump sum will come next year. So, between that and your pension, you are unlikely to see a big drop in income taxes.
January 1
Pensions seem to be a recurring theme. Certain employers’ pension plans credit a year of service, for calculation purposes, on January 1. Similarly, you may get a cost-of-living adjustment by staying until January 1. This varies by employer.
This one makes sense for those who are retiring after required minimum distribution age. The money in your current employer’s retirement plan was exempt from RMDs due to the still-working exception. However, that RMD starts in the year you retire, even if that’s December 31.
In other words, if you retire on December 31, 2023, you will have two RMDs from your employer plan in 2024. The 2023 RMD will have to be taken by April 1, 2024, and the 2024 RMD by December 31, 2024.
If you retire on January 1, you’ll have only the 2024 RMD in December.
Other considerations
Vesting of retirement plans. I have seen six-figure sums left on the table by walking away before employer matches in retirement plans are fully vested. You will always get the money that you contributed. However, the employer match will follow some sort of vesting schedule that you need to outlast in order to keep that money.
Vesting of stock options. Stock options are a retention tool. Any unvested options will be forfeited when you are no longer retained. Here’s the thing: This is a moving finish line. Typically, employers will keep issuing new options on an ever-extending vesting schedule. At some point, you just need to pull off the Band-Aid.
Health care. This maze will be a topic of a future article. The most important thing for our clients is to ensure you have a plan between retirement and Medicare eligibility. Often, COBRA serves as the bridge. If that’s the bridge you want to use, you’ll need to work backward from age 65 to see when you can retire, based on how long your COBRA coverage will last.
People spend too much time trying to game this system. Of course, you don’t want to leave free money on the table, but it’s more important to ensure that you have enough than it is to decide between December 31 and January 1.
If you want one final check of your math, you can use this free software to see where you stand.
Related Content
-
Retire in Costa Rica With These Three Tax BenefitsRetirement Taxes Costa Rica may be a good place for retirement if you like the low cost of living and savings for your heirs.
-
Five Ways to Ease Caregiver StressCaregiver stress is real. Here are five techniques to protect your health and happiness while caring for a loved one.
-
Financial Strategies Borrowed From the Big Game's PlaybookLike the best football teams, you can win at financial planning by executing a strategy, making halftime adjustments and staying focused on the ultimate prize.
-
Three Ways to Plan Now for a Social Security Shortfall LaterThe outlook for Social Security is gloomy, but you can save now to protect against benefit cuts later. If the cuts don't happen, you'll still be better off.
-
Extra Cash? Should You Pay Off Debt or Invest?Depending on your financial situation, you might benefit from paying off debt, investing or both. Here are some things to consider before deciding.
-
The Future of 1031 Exchanges Under Trump Looks BrightAs a real estate investor himself, President Trump appears poised to preserve the tax-deferring power of this strategy. But you still must follow the rules.
-
Gambling vs Investing: How to Tell the DifferenceIt's easy to get caught up in the excitement of placing a bet on the Big Game, but beware of letting that emotion drive your investing decisions.
-
Empowering Widows: Five Goals for Financial Security in 2025Tackling these strategies one at a time, whether it's updating estate planning or reassessing investments, can help put you on track for financial stability.
-
Private Credit: Coming Soon to a Portfolio Near YouPrivate credit could be a good source of diversification for sophisticated investors, but beware of the risks.
-
What Is Insurance Good For? Let Us Count the WaysYou might resent having to pay premiums, but when disaster or just a minor fender-bender happens, you'll be happy you have the financial backup.
