Donor-advised funds (DAFs) are one of the fastest-growing forms of philanthropy in the United States, with over $52 billion granted to charities in 2023.
One of the many benefits of a DAF is the potential for charitable dollars to grow tax-free, which can have a tremendous impact. For example, Daffy members set aside over $105 million for charity last year, and since then, their accounts have grown by over $30 million — an incredible amount raised for charity.
Unfortunately, there is little guidance on developing an investment strategy for a DAF, which is distinctly different from selecting investments for a retirement account. In a retirement account, the primary factors driving investment decisions are typically time horizon and risk tolerance. There’s often a singular goal: building a large enough nest egg to last through retirement.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
In contrast, the goals for a DAF can vary widely. Some donors contribute regularly, matching their annual giving with weekly or monthly deposits. Others contribute opportunistically, overfunding their accounts in profitable years to support giving in leaner times. Additionally, some donors aim to create a long-term fund that supports annual donations to specific charities for decades, or even indefinitely, like an endowment.
As a result, designing the right portfolio for a DAF requires understanding the giving strategy of the donor.
How to match your investment strategy to your giving goals
Let’s explore a few scenarios to demonstrate different strategies donors might use when investing through their DAF.
A pay-as-you-go plan. Let’s imagine a client named Leah. Leah uses her DAF to donate about $5,000 annually to her child’s school, alongside a few other local and national charities. She contributed $2,000 up front to prepare for an upcoming school fundraiser and established recurring monthly contributions of $300 to support her ongoing giving.
Since Leah plans to distribute most of her contributions this year, she would likely benefit from a conservative portfolio allocated to short-term Treasury bills.
A growth plan. Now consider Neal and Sarah. The couple’s income is fairly stable most years, but Neal’s company went public this year, resulting in a substantial stock-based windfall. They usually donate around $10,000 a year, but they decided to contribute $100,000 this year to their DAF to help manage their increased tax burden from Neal’s stock sales. As a result, most of the funds in their portfolio will be invested for five years or more.
For this couple, a low-cost, globally diversified portfolio of stock and bond funds makes sense. They might even include a small allocation to bitcoin. With a tax-free, automatically rebalanced portfolio in a DAF, their portfolio runs little risk of becoming overweight with high-risk assets.
An endowment plan. Finally, meet Lakshmi and Ajay, who have both had successful careers and wish to create a lasting family legacy through their DAF. They have funded their DAF with over $750,000 in low-cost-basis mutual fund shares that they have held for over 20 years, avoiding any capital gains taxes on those investments. They plan to donate $25,000 annually for the next 20 years, with the intent that their children, Justine and Janan, will eventually succeed in managing the fund.
Given their long-term outlook, an aggressive diversified portfolio with growth-focused investments may be ideal, ensuring that their philanthropic efforts can endure for generations.
The impact of a thoughtful DAF investment strategy
The beauty of a DAF is that it offers the flexibility to adapt your investment strategy to your giving goals, no matter how short term or long term they may be. While not all donor-advised platforms in the U.S. offer clients and advisers the flexibility to customize their portfolio, some, like Daffy, give you the flexibility to select from hundreds of high-quality, low-cost ETFs to fit your giving strategy. (Full disclosure: I am a co-founder and the CEO of Daffy.)
For the 50 million to 60 million U.S. households that give to charity every year, giving is not just a one-off transaction. For many households, it is one of the most important financial goals for their family and their legacy.
So whether you’re looking to fund immediate charitable contributions, leverage market opportunities to maximize future donations or create a legacy that will benefit generations to come, matching your DAF portfolio to your giving strategy is key to making a lasting impact.
The information provided is for educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice or recommendations, does not constitute a solicitation to buy or sell securities, and should not be considered specific legal investment or tax advice. To assess your specific situation, please consult with a tax and/or investment professional.
Related Content
-
With TV Drug Ads, What You See Is Not Necessarily What You GetThe U.S. is one of only two countries that legally allows drugmakers to advertise products directly to patients. There are consumer protections in place — but do they go far enough?
-
When Will I Receive My First 2025 Social Security Check?Find out when you can expect your first 2025 Social Security payment and the date you get paid when your scheduled day falls on a holiday.
-
Social Security Payment Schedule for 2025
Find out when you can expect your first 2025 Social Security payment and the date you get paid when your scheduled day falls on a holiday.
-
Longevity Illustrator: Find Out How Long You Might LiveKnowing how long you might live in retirement is critical as you plan your retirement income. Longevity illustrators can offer valuable insights.
-
Could Political Arguments Ruin Your Estate Plan?If you're arguing with loved ones over politics, consider taking a step back before cutting them out of your estate plan. The consequences could be serious.
-
How to Get Dual Citizenship: Pros, Cons and Steps to TakeDual citizenship with countries like Italy, Greece and Saint Lucia has some obvious attractions — but there are drawbacks and hoops to jump through, too.
-
Are You Middle Class?The share of Americans in the middle class has been dwindling for decades. Here's how to tell if you're part of the shrinking middle class.
-
Rattled by RMDs? Look No FurtherThe rules for required minimum distributions (RMDs) have changed in recent years, so here's what to know as the end of the year (and a tax deadline) approaches.
-
Three Reasons for Retirees to Lease a Car Instead of Buy OneIf you're not commuting any longer, the annual mileage caps on leases may not be a concern, and who can complain about getting a new car every three years?
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Close Out Fed Week on a Quiet NoteNike jumped on news it's replacing its CEO, while FedEx slumped on disappointing earnings.
