Americans Are Saving Hard for Retirement, So Why Do So Many Tap 401(k)s in an Emergency? The Answer Isn't Poor Discipline
Don't beat yourself up if you've taken a hardship withdrawal from your 401(k). Balancing saving for retirement with financial security isn't easy. But how can you avoid it in the future?
You've done everything the system has asked of you.
You were automatically enrolled in your 401(k) on your first day and never opted out. Your contribution rate climbs a little each year — automatically, whether you notice or not — and your money sits in a target-date fund that quietly rebalances while you live life.
On paper, you're a retirement success story — the exact "participant outcome" every employer hopes for and the entire financial services industry is built to produce.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Then the brakes on your car go, the emergency room copay hits, or the rent notice arrives with a number you simply can't cover this month. And you do the very thing you swore you'd never do: You log in and pull money out of the account you know you shouldn't touch.
If that stings a little, it's probably because it's a story about a lot of us.
In 2025, a record 6% of retirement plan participants took a hardship withdrawal from their 401(k), according to Vanguard's latest How America Saves report — the largest share the firm has ever recorded, and up from 5% the year before.
That happened in the very same year account balances climbed 13% and plan participation reached an all-time high of 86%. Read that again.
By those measures, the system looks healthier than ever. So why are more people than ever reaching into their retirement savings early? And how can we help mitigate this?
Hardship withdrawals aren't a discipline problem
The "easy" conclusion is that people simply aren't saving well, or that they lack discipline. I'd argue the opposite. The median hardship withdrawal last year was about $1,900. The two most common reasons were to stop a foreclosure or eviction and to cover a medical bill.
People aren't necessarily draining their retirement accounts for a vacation, a new pool in the backyard or an online shopping spree. They're reaching for the last cushion they have, because every other one is already gone.
That's the real story hiding inside the headlines: The early withdrawal isn't the problem. It's a symptom. The fragility was there long before the withdrawal; this is just where it finally became visible.
The rest of the data agrees. Worker confidence in retiring comfortably fell six points in a single year to 61%, the lowest since 2017, according to the Employee Benefit Research Institute. Fewer than three in five workers say they could handle an emergency expense, while 65% say debt is a problem in their household.
These aren't the numbers of a country that forgot how to save. They're the numbers of a country where paychecks stopped stretching as far as the plan assumed they would.
To be fair, part of the increase is mechanical. It's simply easier to take a hardship withdrawal than it used to be thanks to a 2018 rule change that removed a required step, resulting in less paperwork and fewer hoops to jump through.
Going back to the 6% taking withdrawals, this could mean friction is disappearing, not necessarily that distress is appearing. But that caveat doesn't rescue the overall story. In contrast, it sharpens it.
When someone is facing eviction, unexpected medical bills or a $1,900 shortfall and this is what they reach for first, you're not looking at carelessness. You're looking at a need.
A better way to cope with financial emergencies
If you find yourself eyeing that account in a hard month, instead of asking, "What's wrong with me?", ask some of these questions instead.
Am I measuring the right thing? A growing retirement account balance feels like security, but it's a promise about a life you'll live decades from now. It tells you nothing about your next 30 days.
The fragility lives in the gap between this paycheck and the next surprise, and that gap never shows up on your quarterly retirement account statements.
The number that may better predict whether you'll have to raid it is a different one: How long you could cover the basics if the paychecks stopped tomorrow, using money you can easily reach without touching retirement at all.
Is there anything between me and the next emergency that isn't my retirement account? For a lot of people, honestly, there isn't. But that's not a character flaw — it's the most changeable thing on this list.
A small, separate emergency fund, built however it gets built — a little set aside over time — is often all that stands between an unexpected bill and a withdrawal.
And what would actually make me feel secure, as opposed to just making the balance bigger? Those aren't always the same goal, and noticing the difference is where real security starts.
Rather than focusing too rigidly on standard savings advice, find the number that helps you sleep at night.
To be clear, none of this means the years of saving were pointless. It means retirement readiness and financial security are two different things, and we've spent a long time discussing the first as if it guarantees the second.
If you're doing everything right and still feel like you're one surprise away from it all coming apart, you're not imagining it, and you're not alone — you're paying attention. The account is never the whole picture. The life around it is.
Related Content
- 8 Costly 401(k) Mistakes That Could Tank Your Retirement
- The 401(k) Loan Dilemma: Is It Ever a Good Idea?
- 6 Steps to Quickly Build Your Emergency Fund
- How Much Savings Do You Actually Need to Feel Financially Secure? Start With These 3 Benchmarks
- Take It From a Tax Expert: The True Measure of Your Retirement Readiness Isn't the Size of Your Nest Egg
