When it comes to retirement savings, high earners face unique challenges and opportunities. Deciding between pre-tax traditional IRAs/401(k)s and post-tax Roth IRAs/401(k)s is not a one-size-fits-all decision. A well-thought-out strategy tailored to individual circumstances can make a significant difference in retirement outcomes. There are several key considerations for you to make, and your answers can help guide your decision-making process.
Classic deductible IRA and Roth IRA contributions can be out of reach for high earners with workplace retirement plans such as a 401(k)/403b/457s. Married couples filing taxes together are ineligible for 2025 deductible IRA contributions with modified adjusted gross incomes (MAGI) over $146,000. Roth IRA contributions ignore workplace retirement plan involvement, but those married filing jointly become ineligible with MAGI over $246,000.
Luckily, most workplace retirement plans allow employees to choose between traditional or Roth employee retirement plan contributions. According to T. Rowe Price, 93% of 401(k) plans offered Roth employee contribution options as of 2023, with 14% of participants using the feature. While participation seems low, this savings option only arrived in 2006. Traditional and Roth 401(k) contributions are not subject to any income limitations. So how do you choose?
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
1. Evaluate your current and future tax situation
One of the first questions to address is how your tax bracket today compares to your expected tax bracket in retirement.
Traditional accounts allow for tax-deferred growth, with contributions reducing taxable income today. However, required minimum distributions (RMDs) starting at age 73 if born between 1951 and 1959, and age 75 if born after 1960, could push you into a higher tax bracket in retirement. Those mandatory RMDs are taxed as ordinary income.
Roth accounts require paying taxes upfront but offer tax-free growth and withdrawals, making them attractive if you expect to be in a higher tax bracket later.
If you’re planning to retire in a lower-tax state, traditional contributions can make sense but having both traditional and Roth accounts allows flexibility depending on a year-by-year tax situation.
2. Consider your non-retirement investments
High-income households often have significant non-retirement investments that generate capital gains and income. This additional taxable income can influence the decision between Roth and traditional accounts.
Roth assets can provide a tax-free withdrawal option, complementing taxable accounts and giving you flexibility between tax-free and taxable withdrawal options in retirement.
Traditional accounts may defer taxes but could amplify the tax burden when combined with other income sources later in life.
3. Plan for RMDs and charitable giving
Traditional retirement account contributions come with ordinary income generating RMDs. Qualified charitable distributions (QCDs), or sending all or part of that RMD to charity, offers a tax-efficient way to meet RMD requirements for those charitably inclined. In contrast, Roth accounts have no RMDs during the account holder’s lifetime.
4. Think about your legacy and the next generation
The SECURE Act changed rules for most non-spouse inheritors of pre-tax/traditional retirement accounts, requiring those beneficiaries to distribute assets within a 10-year window potentially generating high ordinary income in that decade. Those inheriting Roth assets maintain the tax-free status.
5. Consider a well-timed Roth conversion
For high earners nearing retirement, Roth conversions can be a powerful tool — especially during early retirement years before claiming Social Security. These conversions allow you to “fill up” lower tax brackets gradually, avoiding a tax spike in later years. Many 401(k)/403b/457 plans allow in-plan Roth conversions also.
If pre-tax/traditional accounts make up the majority of your retirement assets, Roth conversions can help reduce future RMD and ordinary income tax obligations. When making conversions, working with a CPA will help you optimize your conversion amounts and ensure accuracy, as recharacterizations are no longer allowed as a result of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
6. Split contributions between Roth and traditional accounts
Many employer-sponsored retirement plans allow for splitting employee contributions between traditional and Roth accounts, offering flexibility. This hybrid approach provides a hedge against future tax uncertainty. Determining the right split involves assessing current income needs, legacy goals and anticipated changes to tax laws or personal circumstances.
More advanced strategies, such as backdoor Roth IRA contributions and mega-backdoor Roth IRA contributions, also exist but are outside the scope of this article.
7. Take advantage of emerging Roth opportunities
High-income households can also take advantage of the higher contribution limits for Roth 401(k)s — up to $31,000 in 2025 for participants aged 50 or older. For more on the implications of the SECURE 2.0 Act, read the post I wrote after the law was enacted, The SECURE Act New Era – Retirement & Financial Planning Reminders.
Beginning in 2026, high-income retirement plan savers over 50 years old must execute their employee deferral catch-up contribution as a Roth. Employer match contributions may increasingly see Roth designation. As federal deficits continue to increase, adoration of Roth contributions by policymakers does too. Receiving tax revenue quickly helps the budget-scoring process of proposed legislation.
Final thoughts: Plan early and remain flexible
Estimating your future bracket can be difficult. Life happens and circumstances can always change. However, for married filing jointly couples currently and expected to remain in the top federal income tax bracket of 37% at over $751,600 of income in 2025, pre-tax/traditional contributions while working likely make sense. For early career savers and those with incomes projected to rise, Roth retirement account contributions can make a lot of sense.
When deciding between Roth and traditional accounts, the right answer depends on your unique situation. Factors such as tax strategy, retirement goals, legacy planning and expected changes in income or family dynamics all play a role.
Starting the conversation early allows for thoughtful planning and flexibility to adapt as circumstances evolve. With the right approach, high earners can maximize their after-tax retirement savings and create a more secure financial future.
This article is provided for informational purposes only, represents only a summary of topics discussed, and does not represent any investment, legal, or tax advice or recommendations. Readers must evaluate their own financial circumstances and needs and are strongly recommended to consult their professional advisors prior to making any decisions about their retirement planning. Certain of the content contained herein also represents the opinions of the author, which are subject to change without notice. Any changes in current laws or regulations could lead to vastly different conclusions from those described herein.
Related Content
-
Bigger Social Security Checks Are Arriving in AprilPayments to eligible retired public sector employees will increase starting in April due to the Social Security Fairness Act (SSFA)..
-
5 CDs to Put Your Tax Refund IntoPlanning to get a tax refund this year? Treat your future self with a risk-free way to grow your money. Here are the 5 best CDs to consider.
-
Bigger Social Security Checks Are Arriving in AprilPayments to eligible retired public sector employees will increase starting in April due to the Social Security Fairness Act (SSFA)..
-
Seven Questions to Ask When Evaluating Personal Loan OptionsTaking out a personal loan too hastily could lock you into unfavorable terms with an untrustworthy lender. Ask these questions before signing anything.
-
Return to Your Home Country to Retire: Repatriation RetirementThey came to the U.S. to live and work, but they want to retire in the old country. Here's how to juggle the move back home.
-
How Much Does Being Rich Matter in Retirement?After a certain point, having more money in retirement won't make you any happier, new research shows. Instead, physical health, a sense of purpose, and a minimal amount of non-mortgage debt are more relevant.
-
The Three Biggest Fears Keeping Retirees Up at NightHere are the steps you can take to put those fears to rest and retire with confidence so you can relax and enjoy the life you've planned.
-
What Can a Donor-Advised Fund Do for You? (A Lot)DAFs and private foundations go about helping charities (and those who donate) in different ways. Each comes with its own benefits and restrictions to navigate.
-
Estate Planning When You Have International AssetsEstate planning gets tricky when you have assets and/or beneficiaries outside the U.S. To avoid costly inheritance mistakes, it pays to understand the basics.
-
Microsoft Stock: Innovation Spurs Its 100,000% ReturnMicrosoft's ability to recognize the "next big thing" has allowed sales – and its share price – to grow exponentially over the years.
