President Trump wants Congress to pass a comprehensive legislative package that he's dubbed "one big, beautiful bill," with a significant emphasis on tax policy.
On his social media platform Truth Social, Trump has championed the "one powerful bill" concept — legislation covering border security, energy policy, and tax cuts. The President also highlighted a populist tax proposal to eliminate taxes on tips while framing his tax proposals as a way to "bring our Country back.”
As he has previously suggested, Trump suggested that tariffs would cover the cost of the bill, positioning it as a win and continuing his economic approach from his first term.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
But with a looming March 14 government funding deadline, a super-narrow majority in the U.S. House of Representatives, and Republicans in the U.S. Senate moving on a border-first, taxes-second approach, a massive reconciliation bill addressing all of these priorities on a tight deadline seems more than ambitious. Here's more to know.
More Trump tax cuts in 'One beautiful bill?
A cornerstone of the bill would be the permanent extension of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA, also known as the “Trump tax cuts”). Key provisions are set to expire at the end of 2025.
However, the proposed "big beautiful bill" would also likely introduce new measures that could impact various income groups.
- For example, Trump is proposing to eliminate taxes on tips, a move that could benefit some service industry workers but cost the federal government significant revenue.
- The bill could include changes to the cap on state and local tax (SALT) deductions that could have support from some Republican and Democrat lawmakers.
To offset the cost of tax cuts, Trump proposes substantial tariff increases. However, as Kiplinger has reported, tariffs can significantly increase the costs of goods and services you rely on and impact your budget.
Trump's energy proposal would focus on expanding drilling rights, repealing clean energy incentives (e.g., possibly eliminating the $7,500 federal EV tax credit), and reducing environmental regulations. The goal seems to be to maximize domestic oil and gas exports while dismantling Biden-era climate policies in the Inflation Reduction Act.
For border security, the bill would likely fund border wall construction, increase deportation, restrict asylum processes, and potentially deploy military resources to enforce immigration.
It's worth noting that the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has estimated that a permanent extension of the TCJA could cost $4.6 trillion over the next ten years. So, without major offsets, extending the tax cuts will likely complicate the debate over federal fiscal policy on Capitol Hill.
Border first? Republicans divided over legislative strategy
By combining multiple policy priorities, Trump apparently wants to increase the chances of passing his agenda despite a narrow Republican majority in the House of Representatives.
House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) has supported this approach, saying his goal would be to pass the package within the first 100 days of Trump's term, potentially by April or May.
"We can put it all together, one big up-or-down vote, which can save the country, quite literally, because there are so many elements to it,” Johnson said in a Fox News interview.
While this may sound good to some, the bill's scope faces hurdles.
Some Republican senators, including newly minted Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota, reportedly favor a border-first approach to enacting Trump's policies.
Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina had voiced concern about combining border security with tax and energy policies.
"I'm very worried that if we don't put border first and get it done, it's going to be a nightmare for our national security," Graham said in a Fox News interview.
He cautioned Republicans about combining border security with other policy priorities, warning that using border security as leverage for tax cuts would be "playing Russian roulette with our national security."
Since then, Senate Republicans have moved forward with the two-bill approach, while House Republicans have taken the first step toward their single reconciliation bill plan.
On February 25, the House passed a budget blueprint proposing $4.5 trillion in tax cuts, a $4 trillion debt limit increase, and approximately $2 trillion in budget cuts. Regarding the blueprint, which is just an initial step toward eventual legislation, House leaders stated in a release, "Today, House Republicans moved Congress closer to delivering on President Trump's full America First agenda --- not just parts of it."
Medicaid cuts?
The House GOP budget blueprint includes potentially hundreds of billions in Medicaid cuts over the next decade to help finance tax cuts that primarily benefit high-income earners. However, once fleshed out, the proposal could face opposition from some Republican lawmakers concerned about the impact on Medicaid recipients in their districts, and critics argue it could lead to millions losing healthcare coverage.
Additionally, the slim five-seat Republican majority in the House leaves little room for dissent within the party, and the bill's complexity will likely make it difficult to reach a consensus on all aspects of an eventual reconciliation bill.
And let's not forget the March 14 government funding deadline could impact Trump's tax agenda by diverting legislative attention and resources away from tax reform. Additionally, the deadline could provide Democrats with negotiating leverage to demand concessions or modifications to Trump's tax proposals in exchange for their support on a spending bill.
Whatever happens will significantly affect U.S. tax policy and your tax bill. Buckle up and stay tuned.
Related
-
Four Roth IRA Pitfalls Your Adviser May Not Tell You AboutYou may not be bound for Mordor, but Roth IRA pitfalls could upend your retirement if you're unaware of them.
-
Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: Which One Is the Better Deal?Walmart+ and Amazon Prime both promise free shipping, exclusive deals, and a suite of add-on services. But which one should you get, if any?
-
Why You May Owe More Tax Soon on Popular Employee BenefitsTax Law Workers could foot the tax bill for employer-provided benefits like parking, gyms, and meals.
-
Are Armed IRS Agents Headed to the Border?IRS Enforcement The Trump administration is considering a controversial move to redeploy some IRS agents.
-
Trump Federal Employee Buyout Offer: What It Means for You NowLaw & Politics The federal deferred resignation program accepted by thousands of workers continues to cause confusion and concern.
-
‘Back to the Old Days’? What’s Wrong With Trump’s Plan to Abolish Income TaxTax Policy The likelihood of Trump eliminating income tax and the IRS remains low, but the ongoing debate highlights the need for tax reform.
-
No New IRS Agents? What Trump’s Federal Hiring Freeze, Firings Mean for Your TaxesIRS Will an executive order and firing IRS workers reshape the federal tax agency and impact how long it takes to get your tax refund?
-
The TCJA May Help Nonprofits Next Year: Here’s WhyTax Law A potential TCJA extension could help nonprofits. But is it enough to keep up with inflation?
-
Election 2024 Childcare Debate: Harris-Walz vs. Trump-Vance PlansElection As Election Day approaches, the Republican and Democratic tickets present different ideas for childcare and family tax credits. Here's what to know.
-
The TCJA: What It Is and How Expiration and Proposed Changes Affect Your TaxesTax Law How will expiring tax cuts impact your wallet?
